Home·The theorem·The proof in one reading·Architecture·Units·Manuscript·Glossary·FAQ·Work items·Data·Method·Provenance·Changes
← III.12 Bounds uniform in the volume and convergence as the spacing tends to zero (notes)Part III·Unit outlineIII.14 The construction run: flat representations and the ultraviolet rate (notes) →

III.13. Extension to all labels: one common Wilson family — detailed notes

Contents

1. What this unit proves 1

2. What it uses 8

3. Strategy 10

4. Steps 11

4.1 Choosing the constants once 11

4.2 Shooting, and the limit at a fixed level 15

4.3 Renormalized observables 16

4.4 Correlations at fixed volume 17

4.5 Reports 19

5. Where the difficulty lies 21

6. Notation 22

7. What remains unexplained 23

The full account of unit III.13: every proposition with its proof sketch, checked against the Lean in two rounds and edited. The condensed outline and the map of the Lean are on the unit page.

Unit page · All units · Overview

Part: III, Ultraviolet construction (renormalization group). Lean: YM/SharpGram/Common.lean, YM/SharpGram/Measured.lean, YM/SharpGram/Assembly/, YM/UVExtension/. Size: about 22,100 lines in the unit inventory. Principal assembly results: multitude, uv_log, multitude_foot.

Place in the proof. This unit supplies the ultraviolet construction for habitat (Proposition III.13.4). The main theorem YangMills.constructed does not use it.

1. What this unit proves

Conventions.

Lean conventions: Test, Extraction.suitable.

Definition (chessboard bound in the schedule). For \(v \in \mathcal{L}_d\), levels \(m \leqslant N\) and \(A \geqslant 0\), the centered budget holds if:

The family has the chessboard bound in the schedule if for every \(d\) and all \(R, \varepsilon > 0\) there is \(A \geqslant 0\) such that, for every level \(m \geqslant \text{ref} (d)\) and all sufficiently large \(N\), the centered budget holds with constant \(A \hspace{0.17em} a_m^{- d - \varepsilon}\) for every period \(p\) and every \(v \in \mathcal{L}_d\) with \(\|v\| \leqslant R\).

Lean: Extraction.Wcmain, centeredBudget.

Proposition III.13.1 (one family for the ultraviolet and logarithmic packages). Let \(G\) be simple and \(b > 0\). There is a Wilson family \(C\) with the following properties.

  1. Its kernel penalty is \(b\).

  2. \(C\) is calibrated. There are a full schedule of constants (sheet, block sizes, protection, delays, bar, wait, chart ratio, prices, post-cost) and a directed history whose trails generate the history of \(C\). Every step from level \(m + 1\) to level \(m\) satisfies the per-step estimates of III.9–III.12.

  3. \(C\) is consistent.

  4. \(C\) has the chessboard bound in the schedule.

  5. \(C\) is floral: it is the centre of an analytic shooting family (Proposition III.13.7).

  6. \(C\) satisfies the three entrance conditions of the OPE:

  7. There are coefficient-map bound data \(W\), allowance indices \(r : \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N}\) and one-step transfer data \(D\) for which two properties hold. Write \(K\) for the bound function supplied by \(W\).

  8. Coverage holds. There is \(g (k) \to \infty\) with \(g (k) \leqslant k\) and \(a_{g (k)} \leqslant \hat{\beta}_k \hspace{0.17em} a_k\) for large \(k\) such that, for every \(d\) and all large \(k\), three probe panels of depth \(d\) are poised at level \(g (k)\) (VII.1).

  9. For every extraction order \(F\) satisfying the cell hypotheses (IV.1), the grid approximation property holds at arbitrarily fine fixed levels, for bounded label degrees and the reflection pairs allowed in III.11. Complete weak comparison systems exist for every finite demand and degree horizon, every positive radius bound, and every real-spin structure on the smooth free comparison table.

  10. For every extraction order \(f\) there are:

Status: theorem. The only hypotheses are \(G\) simple and \(b > 0\).

Lean: uv_log. The predicates, in the order of the items: Spec.Calibrated, Family.Makes, Oasis.Floral, Acme.Aroma, LogPackage, TrueSteps with CalibratedStep, Dense.Coverage, Org.Grill, East.CompleteWeak, Next.Extract.Base, Spec.Seed, Maxwell.Ranks. The engineering rescaling and leading map are Bid.vowel and Heading.leads.

Proposition III.13.2 (the coordinated family). Let \(G\) be simple and \(b > 0\). There is one Wilson family \(C\) with the following properties:

In addition, for every extraction order \(F\) there are a refinement \(g\) and a table \(T\) such that:

Status: theorem. The family is chosen before \(F\).

Lean: coordination, Extraction.Order.Ordered, OPE.Facilities, Spec.Final.

Proposition III.13.3 (the common family, all phases). Let \(G\) be simple, \(b > 0\), and let \(f\) be an extraction order. There are a family \(C\), a refinement \(g\), a table \(T\), a construction record \(F\) for \((C, f \circ g, T)\) and a reconstruction record \(\mathcal{A}\) for every phase of \(F\) (V.3) such that:

Status: theorem. In the statement \(C\) is quantified after \(f\). The proof takes \(C\) from III.13.2, so in fact one family serves all \(f\).

Lean: common, EveryPhase.Completed, EveryPhase.Almanac, OPE.AllShapes.

Proposition III.13.4 (headline: moving-frame Gram limits on the common family). Let \(G\) be simple, \(b > 0\), and let \(f\) be an extraction order. There are \(C, g, T, F, \mathcal{A}, P\) as in III.13.3 with all of its conclusions. In addition, coverage holds at the cutoff of \(F\), and the following holds for every ultrafilter \(\mathcal{U}\) on \(\mathbb{N} \times \mathbb{N}\) finer than the filter of \(f \circ g\) ("period index large, then mesh index large") and every depth \(D\):

  1. Moving-frame portfolios of depth \(D\) along \(\mathcal{U}\) exist. A portfolio consists of:

  2. For every portfolio \(X\) there are linear isomorphisms \(Y_k (d)\) from the degree-\(d\) field space of the free Maxwell table onto that of \(T\) (\(d \leqslant D\), \(k \in \mathbb{N}\)), with the following properties.

Status: theorem; headline declaration. In the statement \(C\) is quantified after \(f\), as in III.13.3.

Lean: habitat, Weak.Portfolio, PricedIn. (proof of the wrapper read)

Proposition III.13.5 (fixed-volume limit with \(k\) derivatives). Let \(C\) be as in III.13.1, and fix \(d, k \in \mathbb{N}\). For all sufficiently large periods \(p\) (the threshold depends on \(d\) and \(k\)), every \(n\), and all labels \(v_1, \ldots, v_n\) of degrees \(\leqslant d\), there is a function \(g\) on \((\mathbb{R}^4)^n\) such that, as \(N \to \infty\) along the whole sequence:

  1. \(g\) is continuous on \(\Omega^n_p\). The lattice correlation functions \(x \mapsto \langle \prod_i O^{N, p}_{v_i} (x_i) \rangle_{N, p}\), extended periodically and then as step functions using coordinatewise ceiling projection onto \((a_N \mathbb{Z}^4)^n\), converge to \(g\) uniformly on compact subsets of \(\Omega^n_p\).

  2. For every word \(u\) of at most \(k\) coordinate directions, the step-function extensions of the normalized forward differences converge to \(\partial_u g\) uniformly on compact subsets of \(\Omega^n_p\). The same limit is obtained by multilinear interpolation of any fixed word of normalized coordinate differences with positive integer step lengths and fixed integer stencil offsets, including forward, backward and centred differences.

  3. On \(\Omega^n_p\) these iterated directional derivatives exist: \(\partial_a (\partial_u g) = \partial_{(a, u)} g\) whenever the word \(u\) has length \(< k\).

  4. For every test function \(t\) admissible at period \(p\), \(tg\) is integrable and \(a_N^{4 n} \sum_r t (r) \hspace{0.17em} \langle \prod_i O^{N, p}_{v_i} (r_i) \rangle_{N, p} \to \int tg\), where the sum is over the centred representatives of the torus lattice.

Status: theorem.

Lean: Poppy.Margins, Poppy.bravo, Poppy.blossoms.

Proposition III.13.6 (convergence at separated lattice points). Let \(C^{\mathbf{s}}\) be a member of the shooting family of III.13.7. At a fixed period \(p\), assume:

Let \(J \in \mathbb{N}\), let \(u_1, \ldots, u_I\) be labels with \(\text{ref} (\deg u_i) \leqslant J\), and let \(o_1, \ldots, o_I\) be pairwise distinct sites of the level-\(J\) lattice of the period-\(p\) torus. Then the sequence

\(\displaystyle \Psi_N = \left\langle \prod_{i = 1}^I O^{N, p}_{u_i} (o_i) \right\rangle_{N, p},\)

with \(o_i\) read as sites of \(\Lambda_{N, p}\), converges as \(N \to \infty\). Status: theorem. For the family of III.13.1, \(\mathbf{s} \equiv 0\).

Lean: Hearth.food.

Proposition III.13.7 (the family is the centre of an analytic shooting family). For the family \(C\) of III.13.1 there are:

such that the following holds.

  1. Shooting. There is \(r_{\ast} > 0\), depending only on the schedule, such that for all \(N, p\) and every real \(s\) with \(|s| < r_{\ast}\) there is exactly one Wilson coupling whose trajectory under the fixed recursion stays in the prescribed scalar coupling bands and reaches \(\bar{\beta} + s\) at level \(0\). For an assignment \(\mathbf{s}= (s_{N, p})\) of real shifts with \(|s_{N, p} | < r_{\ast}\), let \(C^{\mathbf{s}}\) be the Wilson family with these trajectories and the labels, sections and reference levels of the bundle. Then \(C = C^{\boldsymbol{0}}\).

  2. Analyticity, uniform in the cutoff. For \(m \leqslant N\), the level-\(m\) coupling \(\beta_m (N, p ; s)\) and the normalized activity readings of the level-\(m\) effective action extend holomorphically to \(|s| < r_{\ast}\). They are bounded there by \(3 \hat{\beta}_m\) and by \(\text{soft} = \text{rim} / 8\) respectively. For fixed \(m, p\) they converge as \(N \to \infty\), with all derivatives in \(s\), locally uniformly on the disc.

  3. Bounds. \(C\) satisfies the calibration package (with constant allowance) and the priced sup bounds. For every assignment \(\mathbf{s}\), \(C^{\mathbf{s}}\) satisfies the label-transfer and remainder bounds and has the chessboard bound in the schedule. Extraction base data exist at the centre.

  4. Analytic transfer data. There is \(a > 0\), with its disc contained in the shooting domain, on which the bundle has holomorphic coefficient and transfer data for all \(d, N, p\) with \(\text{ref} (d) \leqslant N\). In particular, the inverse terminal label maps extend holomorphically there.

  5. Analytic correlations. Fix \(d, m\). For all large \(p\), every \(n\) and labels of degree \(\leqslant d\), there are \(b' > 0\) and functions \(W_N (z, x)\), holomorphic in \(|z| < b'\), and \(f (z, \cdot)\) on \((\mathbb{R}^4)^n\) such that:

Status: theorem (part of III.13.1). The full-mesh ordered limits in §4.5 use the real shooting trajectories and the bounds of item 3; they do not use the analytic correlation limits of item 5.

Lean: Oasis.Floral, Oasis.Spring, Upland.Arc, Mast.Cellar, Cellar.yard, Harvest.Barn, Gale.Circuit, Beach.Shoal, Beach.Realizes. (definitions and producing proofs read)

2. What it uses

Inputs from other units.

Standard mathematics used.

Imported constants and assumptions. The statements of III.13.1–III.13.4 have no hypotheses beyond \(G\) simple and \(b > 0\). The one-loop slope \(\kappa_G\) enters the coupling-shift estimate (Lemma 4.3) through the hypothesis the annulus calculation, which III.7 proves for every simple \(G\). The construction fixes the following constants:

The analytic argument uses \(\text{soft} = \text{rim} / 8 < 1\), \(\text{rad} = \text{rim} / 4\) and the gain \(e^{(\sigma_k - \sigma_m) / 8}\).

3. Strategy

The order of choice. Each estimate of III.9–III.12, and each requirement of the later parts (OPE with logarithmic corrections, coverage, weak comparison), has the form "there is a threshold beyond which the property holds". It is also stable under further raising: in the preorders on delays, waits and wages, and under decreasing the protection. Successive raises meet the finitely many requirements while preserving this order: sheet → block sizes → wages → protection → delays → bar → wait.

Increasing stage parameters (Taylor order \(6 + i\), power \(2 + i\)) accommodate the countably many label degrees: degree \(d\) is required only from its fixed reference level \(\text{ref} (d)\) onwards.

Shooting and convergence at a fixed level.

  1. The family is the member \(s = 0\) of a one-parameter family in which the terminal coupling at level \(0\) is \(\bar{\beta} + s\). For each cutoff \(N\) the trajectory is found by shooting: it is the fixed point of a contraction with rate \(1 / 2\), uniformly in \(N\).

  2. This uniformity, the convergence of the background fields and coupling shifts at each level (Lemma 4.7), and an \(\text{soft}^v\) decay of the influence of levels far above \(m\) together give convergence, as \(N \to \infty\) along the whole sequence, of the coupling and the effective action at any fixed level \(m\), for every real \(s\) in the shooting disc (Lemma 4.8).

  3. Holomorphic extension in \(s\) to a disc independent of \(N\) and \(p\), with uniform bounds, and Vitali's theorem upgrade this to locally uniform convergence of all derivatives in \(s\) on the disc (Lemma 4.9).

From the effective action to correlations. A correlation of renormalized observables at distinct points is handled in three steps.

  1. RG identity. For a function of the level-\(k\) variables, its conditional average through the block-spin kernels has Wilson expectation equal to its expectation in the level-\(k\) effective measure. That measure converges as \(N \to \infty\) (Lemmas 4.11–4.12).

  2. Coarse approximation. Each fine renormalized observable is close to the conditional average of a level-\(k\) observable whose coefficients converge as \(N \to \infty\). The error is measured in the chessboard norm and is small for \(k\) large, because the gain \(e^{(\sigma_k - \sigma_m) / 8}\) beats the subexponential growth of the costs (Lemma 4.13).

  3. Product estimate. The chessboard product inequality turns these one-point approximations into an approximation of the product (Lemma 4.14).

A Cauchy argument then gives Proposition III.13.6. Proposition III.13.5 follows by Arzelà–Ascoli: there is convergence on the dense set of grid points of all levels, and there is equicontinuity from uniform bounds on lattice differences of order \(k + 1\). Those bounds need a non-degeneracy ("slicing") of the label snapshots, which is known only for large periods, so the fixed-volume statement holds for \(p\) large. The reports then feed this family to the OPE entrance, reconstruction and Gram machinery defined in other units.

Balaban's estimates are used only through the per-step package; what this unit adds is the analysis just described and the order of choice.

4. Steps

4.1 Choosing the constants once

Lemma 4.1 (the step package with all later constants raised). Let \(G\) be simple. Fix the purchased sheet, prices, numerical bounds, scope, tariffs and block-size floor of Lemma 4.2, and assume that, for every stage pair \(i \leqslant j \leqslant i + 1\) with \(i\) beyond the first stage and every \(d + 3 \leqslant i\), the local-section and nonconstant-label expansion costs are bounded by the supplied budget at stage \(j\). Let \(PB, P_2 : \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N}\) be arbitrary allowance sequences. There is a floor \(f \geqslant v_0\) on the block sizes such that, for every block-size sequence \(L \geqslant f\), the following holds.

Sketch: The per-step estimates are supplied in the required order of choice. Successive delay raises add the later requirements. Each raise is a lemma "there is \(V' \geqslant V\) such that every \(Y \geqslant V'\) has the property". Raise the entry-coupling threshold pointwise by taking its maximum with the shooting threshold. Every subsequent delay increase preserves the preceding estimates.

Lean: multitude, uv_commerce. (proof of multitude read; uv_commerce read only as far as its call to Roof.uv_timberT)

Lemma 4.2 (the purchased sheet). Let \(G\) be simple, \(K\) kernel choices for which every patch branches, and \(v\) stage data satisfying the following conditions:

For every two allowance sequences there are a sheet with kernel \(K\) and stage data \(v\), prices, a budget sequence and a bound \(W\), chosen before the tariffs and scopes. For every tariff and scope there is then a block-size floor above the sheet floor such that Lemma 4.1 applies to every larger block-size sequence.

Sketch: Choose the sheet using three inputs:

Then apply Lemma 4.1.

Lean: multitude_foot, sailsV, office, profiles. (proof of multitude_foot read; the others statement only)

Lemma 4.3 (the one-loop running of the marginal coupling). Let \(G\) be simple. Fix kernel choices, a stage \(J\), a colour direction, positive tolerances \(\varepsilon, w, \delta\), and nonnegative \(D, Z, C, Z'\). There are \(\kappa \geqslant 0\) and \(s > 0\) with the following property. For all \(\tau, \text{pace} > 0\) and \(A \geqslant 0\) satisfying the annulus calculation of III.7 with parameters \((G, w, \varepsilon, D, Z, \tau, A)\), there are:

such that every sequence of step data with stage \(J\), block size \(L \geqslant u\), diverging coarse side lengths, and the comparison hypotheses of III.7 admits the following data. Those hypotheses include input and output covariance strip bounds, input path bounds, admissible forests and charts, spectral gap and criticality estimates, heat bounds, direct clip bounds \(Z, Z'\), a positive gap parameter and amplitude \(\Lambda \geqslant 1\). The output consists of:

\(\displaystyle | \alpha + \kappa_G \log L| + 1 \leqslant d ;\)

The annulus calculation supplies a comparison quadratic form whose coupling shift differs from \(- \kappa_G \log L\) by a constant independent of \(L\). Its conclusion applies to all odd \(L\) beyond a threshold under the input path, covariance, floor and compatibility assumptions of III.7.

Sketch: \(\alpha\) is compared with the coupling shift of the annulus comparison form, and the two bounds are added. The constant \(d\) is chosen before \(L\), so the error is bounded uniformly in \(L\).

Lean: ceilings, colorReady, HorizCalc. (the part of the proof of ceilings that bounds \(\alpha\) read; colorReady statement only)

Lemma 4.4 (the bundle and the joint offers). Let \(G\) be simple, \(K\) kernel choices for which every patch branches, \(v\) satisfying the stage conditions of Lemma 4.2 and having support exponents \(\geqslant 100\), and \(Q, Q_2 : \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N}\) monotone with values \(\geqslant 1\). There are:

such that for every block-size sequence \(k \geqslant \tau\) rolls exist, and the following holds through the quantifier chain of Lemma 4.1. In that chain the waits receive one more raise \(Z\), of readiness, minimal length and window. Every level system paid by this raised wait and satisfying the divisor property then carries:

and the family \(C^{\boldsymbol{0}}\) built from the bundle has the following properties:

In addition:

Sketch: Lemma 4.2 supplies the schedule. Increase the block-size floor to ensure \(\text{rate} (L) (1 + 2 \hspace{0.17em} \text{columns}) \hspace{0.17em} \text{orbitCost} \leqslant \text{barunit} (L)\), then construct the bundle. The relay supply and a further wait increase give weak comparison systems. The leases and target rates give the common disc for holomorphic transfer.

Lean: havens_log, jointOffers, Gale.sheaf. (proof of jointOffers read; statement and opening of havens_log read)

Lemma 4.5 (instantiation). Proposition III.13.1 follows from Lemma 4.4 with the following choices.

Then:

Lean: uv_log, Axial.viable.

4.2 Shooting, and the limit at a fixed level

Lemma 4.6 (shooting). Let \(r_{\ast} > 0\) be the radius of the arc; it depends only on the schedule. For all \(N, p\) and real \(|s| < r_{\ast}\):

Lean: Arc.exists_trial, Oasis.spring, Spire.Uses. (the wrappers read; existence and uniqueness come from the fitted structure, statement only)

Lemma 4.7 (kinematic convergence at each level). Fix a paid level system, the horizon and chart data, a colour direction, the small positive pulse parameter, the one-step kinematic estimates and the limiting covariance data supplied by Lemma 4.2. There are background paths and coupling shifts \(\alpha_N (m)\) satisfying all kinematic step estimates such that, for every level \(m\):

Lean: Reward.work item, Reward.turning. (proof of work item read; turning statement only)

Lemma 4.8 (ultraviolet convergence at a fixed level, real shifts). Fix the shooting structure and assume its one-step continuity property and the kinematic convergence of Lemma 4.7; both are supplied by the arc. For every real \(s\) in the analytic domain, every level \(m\) and every period \(p\), two quantities converge as \(N \to \infty\) along the whole sequence: the effective activities at level \(m\), and the level-\(m\) coupling data of the trajectory ending at \(\bar{\beta} + s\).

Sketch:

  1. Contraction. The trajectory with cutoff \(N\) is the fixed point of a map on coupling sequences. Its \(k\)-th iterate from \(0\) lies within \(\text{rad} \cdot 2^{1 - k}\) of the fixed point, uniformly in \(N\).

  2. Stability. If the level-\((m + 1)\) data converge as \(N \to \infty\), so do the level-\(m\) data and the claimed coupling shift of the step. By induction on \(k\), every iterate therefore converges level by level. The coupling shifts converge by Lemma 4.7.

  3. Decay of far-ultraviolet influence. The level-\(m\) activities depend on the levels above \(m + v\) only up to \(\text{soft}^v\) with \(\text{soft} < 1\), uniformly in \(N\).

  4. Conclusion. An \(\varepsilon / 4\) argument closes each step: in a complete space, a sequence that can be approximated uniformly by convergent sequences converges.

Lean: Camp.artistry, Camp.climb, Camp.income, Camp.Sign, Camp.trim. (proof read; the contraction rate and the \(\text{soft}^v\) decay are taken from statements)

Lemma 4.9 (Vitali, and analyticity uniform in the cutoff). Let \(r > 0\) and let \(F_N\) be holomorphic on \(|z| < r\) with values in a complex Banach space, uniformly bounded, and convergent at every real \(z \in (- r, r)\). Then there is a holomorphic \(f\) on the disc such that every iterated derivative of \(F_N\) converges to that of \(f\), locally uniformly. The lemma applies to \(\beta_m (N, p ; \cdot)\) (bounded by \(3 \hat{\beta}_m\)) and to the normalized level-\(m\) activity readings (bounded by \(\text{soft}\)). With Lemma 4.8 this gives III.13.7.2.

Lean: Camp.viva, Camp.SummitUV, Arc.uv.

4.3 Renormalized observables

Lemma 4.10 (label transfer). Fix the shooting structure, coefficient bundle and reference levels of Lemma 4.4.

Lean: Mast.Cellar, Cellar.gate, Lacing.compose, repriseQ, acclaim, antilles. (Cellar definition read; the Lacing lemmas statement only)

4.4 Correlations at fixed volume

Lemma 4.11 (the RG identity). Let the history be selected, \(m \leqslant N\), and \(F\) a bounded measurable function of the level-\(m\) configuration. Let \(B_{N \to m} F\) be its conditional average obtained by iterating the block-spin kernels from level \(m\) to level \(N\). Then

\(\displaystyle \langle B_{N \to m} F \rangle_{N, p} = \frac{\int \rho_{m, N, p} (U) F (U) \hspace{0.17em} d \text{Haar} (U)}{\int \rho_{m, N, p} (U) \hspace{0.17em} d \text{Haar} (U)},\)

where \(\rho_{m, N, p}\) is the effective density with its field-independent scalar factor removed.

Sketch: Iterating the one-step density identity gives the effective measure at level \(m\). Duality with the conditional averaging kernels and equality of partition functions give the formula; the removed scalar factor cancels in the ratio.

Lean: Hearth.scaledK, Hearth.tasting, GridApprox.back, GridApprox.backTo.

Lemma 4.12 (convergence of the effective measure at a fixed level). Fix the arc and its coefficient bundle. At a fixed period \(p\), let the shifts satisfy \(s_{N, p} \to s\) with \(s\) real in the disc. If \(F_N\) are bounded measurable functions of the level-\(m\) configuration and form a uniformly Cauchy sequence, then the level-\(m\) effective expectations of \(F_N\) converge as \(N \to \infty\).

Sketch: The effective densities with their scalar factors removed converge uniformly, by stability of the trajectory family. Their integrals have a uniform positive lower bound. The effective expectations are ratios of convergent integrals.

Lean: Hearth.arrival, Hearth.seating, strippedOn, zPositive, Mast.signs. (proof of arrival read; the three inputs statement only)

Lemma 4.13 (coarse approximation of renormalized observables). Fix the arc and coefficient bundle. At period \(p\), assume the shifts converge to a real shift in the shooting disc, and assume the transfer and remainder estimates and slow-growth bounds of III.13.6. Let \(J \leqslant m \leqslant k\), with \(\text{cs}_m^2 \leqslant a_J / a_m\). Require enough separation for the supports of the degree-\(d\) coarse observables: \(2 (a_k r_d + \text{tail}_k) < a_J\), where \(r_d\) is their fixed support radius and \(\text{tail}_k = 30 a_k (J (k) + 5)\) bounds the reach of the later kernels. Let \(u\) be a degree-\(d\) label with \(\text{ref} (d) \leqslant m\), and let \(w > 0\) satisfy

\(\displaystyle w \hspace{0.17em} a_m^{- d} \cdot 4 (1 + \text{columns}_k) \hspace{0.17em} e^{- (\sigma_k - \sigma_m) / 8} \leqslant \tfrac{1}{2} \hspace{0.17em} \text{fly}_{d, m} .\)

Then there are level-\(k\) observables \(g_N = \sum_j c_j (N) \hspace{0.17em} \Lambda_j\) with the following properties:

For fixed \(d, m, J, u\) and every \(\zeta, \varepsilon > 0\), all sufficiently large \(k\) admit \(w > 0\) with \(wa_m^{- d} 4 (1 + \text{columns}_k) e^{- (\sigma_k - \sigma_m) / 8} \leqslant \zeta / 2\) and \(\text{stock}_k (u) \text{stakes} (J, m) / w \leqslant \varepsilon\). Apply this with \(\zeta = \text{fly}_{d, m}\). The product of the two requirements tends to \(0\), because columns and stock grow subexponentially in \(\sigma_k\) while \(e^{(\sigma_k - \sigma_m) / 8}\) grows exponentially.

Lean: Hearth.peeling, Hearth.seatingM. (proofs read; the level-\(k\) representation itself is statement only)

Lemma 4.14 (chessboard product estimate). Assume the Wilson measure satisfies the reflection-positivity and translation properties for the level-\(h\) tiling. Let \(O_i, Z_i\) be bounded measurable observables supported in its reference cell, with chessboard roots \(\|O_i \| \leqslant c_i\) and \(\|Z_i - O_i \| \leqslant e_i\), and let \(a_i\) be distinct sites of the level-\(h\) lattice. Then

\(\displaystyle \left. \left. | \left\langle \prod_i Z_i \right( \cdot + a_i) \right\rangle - \left\langle \prod_i O_i \right( \cdot + a_i) \right\rangle | \leqslant \prod_i (e_i + c_i) - \prod_i c_i .\)

Sketch: Expand \(Z_i = O_i + (Z_i - O_i)\) and subtract the term containing only the \(O_i\). Apply the chessboard inequality to each remaining product on distinct cells; summing gives the displayed bound.

Lean: GridApprox.tariff, applied in Hearth.banquet. (tariff statement only; banquet proof read)

Proof of Proposition III.13.6.

  1. The chessboard bound in the schedule gives, for each \(i\), a bound \(t_i\) on the chessboard root of \(O_{u_i}\) at level \(J\).

  2. Fix \(q > 0\). Choose \(k\) large and weights \(w_i\) by Lemma 4.13, so that each error is \(\leqslant q\). The support separation makes conditional averaging commute with the product of translated coarse observables. The RG identity (Lemma 4.11) and the chessboard product estimate (Lemma 4.14) then give a sequence \(F_N\) such that, for large \(N\), \(|F_N - \Psi_N | \leqslant \Phi (q) := \prod (q + t_i) - \prod t_i\). Here \(F_N\) is the level-\(k\) effective expectation of the product of the translated \(g^{(i)}_N\), and it converges by Lemma 4.12.

  3. Since \(\Phi\) is continuous with \(\Phi (0) = 0\), one can choose \(q\) with \(\Phi (q) < \varepsilon / 4\). The triangle inequality through two terms of the convergent approximating sequence shows that \((\Psi_N)\) is Cauchy.

Lean: Hearth.food, Hearth.closet.

Lemma 4.15 (slicing for large periods).

Definition. Slicing\((d, p)\) holds if there are:

such that, for large \(N\), \(a \|x\| \leqslant \sum_i \| \text{snapshot}_i (N, p) x\|\) for \(x \in U\).

Statement. Assume a fixed presentation identifying the finite-cutoff kernels of the label projections with the transported Maxwell equation ideals. Suppose every admissible snapshot at every fixed period converges, and every extraction order has a refinement with base data whose projections agree with this presentation. Then Slicing\((d, p)\) holds for all large \(p\). For the bundle of III.13.7 the conclusion takes this form: for each \(d\) and all large \(p\) there is \(\delta > 0\) such that Slicing holds for every assignment of shifts with \(|s_{N, p} | \leqslant \delta\) eventually.

Sketch: By contradiction. A sequence of bad periods defines an extraction order. Along a refinement, finite detection on the range of the limiting projection gives Slicing at all large indices.

Lean: Harvest.rootwards, Harvest.Slicing, Barn.ripe.

Lemma 4.16 (proof of Proposition III.13.5). Fix \(d, k\) and \(p\) beyond the slicing threshold for the degrees up to \(d + k + 1\). Use the arc and bundle hypotheses of Lemma 4.4, zero shifts, and labels of degree \(\leqslant d\). Then:

  1. Dense set. On the points of \(\Omega^n_p\) whose coordinates lie on the level-\(m\) grid for some \(m \geqslant \max \text{ref}\) (a dense set), the lattice correlations converge by III.13.6.

  2. Uniform difference bounds. Slicing and the label-transfer bounds give bounds on lattice differences of order \(\leqslant k + 1\), uniform in \(N\) on compact subsets of \(\Omega^n_p\). Hence the correlations and their differences of order \(\leqslant k\) are asymptotically equicontinuous there.

  3. Arzelà–Ascoli. It gives locally uniform convergence to a continuous \(g\), and to continuous limits of the difference quotients. These limits are the iterated derivatives of \(g\).

  4. Smeared limits. For admissible tests, the smeared correlations converge by dominated convergence, with domination by the uniform period-\(p\) bound.

Lean: Poppy.blossoms, Poppy.coveringR, Extraction.growFrom, Poppy.nourishing, Poppy.mature; difference bounds: Fallow.reaped. (proofs read through the stated transfer estimates)

Lemma 4.17 (analytic dependence of the correlations on the shift). Assume the arc, bundle bounds, paid schedule, analytic transfer disc, leases and target rate bound of Lemma 4.18. Fix \(d, m\), a period \(p\) with slicing stable for all degrees through \(d + m + 1\) for sufficiently small shifts, and finitely many labels of degree \(\leqslant d\). There is \(b' > 0\) such that, for all sufficiently large \(N\), the lattice correlations extend holomorphically to \(|z| < b'\). On every compact subset of \(\Omega^n_p\), their lattice differences through order \(m\) have bounds uniform in \(N\) and \(z\) throughout this disc. At arbitrary lattice configurations the bound supplied at each cutoff may depend on \(N\).

Sketch: Slicing gives uniform real difference bounds through one higher order. The analytic transfer estimates and complex correlation bounds permit the Banach-valued Vitali argument on each separated compact set. The resulting limits have the spatial derivatives and smeared limits of III.13.7.5. Shrinking the disc once more incorporates every cutoff at which all reference levels fit. At each fixed level and period, the normalized effective densities have bounded holomorphic extensions; after shrinking the disc, the moduli of their partition integrals are bounded away from zero uniformly over the allowed cutoffs.

Lean: Beach.inlet, Beach.sparksP, Beach.keep_prefix, Pier.roomR, Pier.mounted. (proofs of sparksP and keep_prefix read; inlet, roomR and mounted statement only)

4.5 Reports

Lemma 4.18 (the centre is floral). Assume:

Then the member \(s = 0\) is floral.

Sketch: The shooting and analyticity properties come from the arc (Lemmas 4.6, 4.9). For large \(p\), the analytic correlation data come from Lemma 4.17.

Lean: Oasis.survives.

Lemma 4.19 (mesh limits along the full sequence). For a floral family \(C\), an extraction order \(f\) and a table \(T\) with a construction record for \((C, f, T)\), the order (full mesh sequence, periods of \(f\)) is ordered for \(T\).

Sketch: At each fixed period there are tables whose smeared limits are taken along the full mesh sequence; they come from Proposition III.13.6 with shift \(0\), through the fixed-period smearing theorem. The record supplies the limit along the mesh subsequence of \(f\), and uniqueness of limits identifies the two.

Lean: Reports.full_tests, Reports.useFull.

Lemma 4.20 (assembly of the reports).

Lean: coordination, common, habitat, fromCoverage, attains. (proofs of the three reports and of fromCoverage read; attains read to the level of its two inputs)

Lemma 4.21 (further estimates used in choosing the step constants).

Lean: Linden.lives, Copse.tangled, Concert.basisE, Lamppost.forge.

5. Where the difficulty lies

Fixed-level convergence requires control of arbitrarily many ultraviolet levels. The contraction estimate and the \(\text{soft}^v\) bound give two uniform approximations by convergent sequences. For correlations, Lemma 4.13 balances exponentially improving coarse approximation against subexponential coefficient costs; the chessboard inequality then controls products.

The derivative limit holds only for sufficiently large periods, with threshold depending on the degree and derivative order. Slicing gives a lower bound on a subspace of the required dimension. The plain smeared limit, used in Lemma 4.19, holds at every fixed period.

The coupling and activity analyticity holds in one disc for all cutoffs and periods. The analytic correlation disc may depend on the finite label family and the period. The construction fixes support exponent \(100\) and target rate \(- 7 / 16\); no alternative rate is asserted here.

The family in III.13.2 is chosen before the extraction order. III.13.3 and III.13.4 state a weaker quantifier order, but their proofs use that same choice. The main theorem follows the separate construction route of III.14; equality of the families produced by the two routes is not asserted.

6. Notation

Written proof Lean Meaning
\(C\) Family Wilson family: history, holonomy data, label frames, local sections, reference levels, transfer data
\(\beta_{N, p}\) Family.beta Wilson coupling at cutoff \(N\), period \(p\)
consistent Family.Makes selected trajectory, sound sections, stage and stencil conditions, priced bounds, calibrated transfer
calibrated Spec.Calibrated history generated by a full schedule with per-step estimates
\(\text{ref} (d)\) Family.ref reference level of degree \(d\)
penalty \(b\) KernelChoices.penalty coefficient of the Gaussian block-spin term
sheet, rolls, wages, \(\theta\), delays, bar, wait, paid Sheet, Rolls, Return.Wages, Protection, Delays, Bar, Wait, Paid constants in the order of choice
alloy, factor, directed history Alloy, Roost.Factor, Directed a schedule of RG steps with their bounds
shooting structure, arc, \(r_{\ast}\) Spire.Uses, Upland.Arc, Arc.radius trajectories ending at \(\bar{\beta} + s\); disc of analyticity
shift \(s\), assignment \(\mathbf{s}\) Orchard.Rose, Orchard.Keys, Mast.roseA (\(\mathbf{s}= 0\)) real shift of the terminal coupling
label-transfer bundle, \(C^{\mathbf{s}}\) Mast.Cellar, Cellar.yard coefficient and transfer data for every shift assignment; the associated family
floral Oasis.Floral, Oasis.Spring III.13.7
bundle conditions Harvest.Barn Scrim bounds and scheduled chessboard bound for all shifts; base data at the centre
chessboard bound in the schedule Extraction.Wcmain §1 definition
fixed-volume limit with \(k\) derivatives Poppy.Margins III.13.5
slicing Harvest.Slicing Lemma 4.15
logarithmic OPE package OPE.Log.LogPackage III.13.1.7
calibrated label steps SharpGram.TrueSteps III.13.1.7
coverage Dense.Coverage III.13.1.8
OPE entrance conditions Acme.Aroma III.13.1.6
grid approximants, weak comparison systems Org.Grill, East.CompleteWeak III.13.1.9
OPE services OPE.Facilities services of VII.4 with a log package
construction record, reconstruction for every phase Spec.Final, EveryPhase.Almanac, EveryPhase.Completed II.2, V.3
portfolio Weak.Portfolio moving-frame probe data along an ultrafilter
effective expectation Hearth.tasting normalized expectation against the effective density with its scalar factor removed
\(B_{N \to m}\) GridApprox.backTo iterated conditional averaging through the block-spin kernels
\(V_L\) Bid.vowel engineering rescaling by \(L^{d - e}\) on grade \(e\)
\(\text{stock}_k (u)\) stockK coefficient bound with subexponential growth in \(\sigma_k\)
\(\text{stakes} (J, m)\) stakes fixed-scale chessboard comparison cost
\(\text{fly}_{d, m}\) Bandage.fly positive allowance in the label-transfer estimate
\(\text{soft}\), \(\text{rad}\), gain Camp.soft, Camp.rad, Bid.gainChart \(\text{rim} / 8\), \(\text{rim} / 4\), \(e^{(\sigma_k - \sigma_m) / 8}\)

7. What remains unexplained

  1. Quantitative packages. The shell estimates in the OPE entrance condition, the full transfer, remainder, sup and weak comparison bounds, and the one-step comparison assumptions in Lemma 4.3 retain their contracts from III.7, III.11 and VII.4. Their complete expansion into conventional notation remains to be written there. The summaries here do not replace those contracts.

  2. Proofs not fully checked. The detailed constant issuers underlying Lemmas 4.1–4.4, the fitted recursion behind Lemma 4.6, the contraction and far-level decay estimates in Lemma 4.8, the one-step label estimates behind Lemma 4.10, and the auxiliary estimates in Lemma 4.21 are used as stated. Their internal proofs have not all been checked. The difference estimate in Lemma 4.16 is traced through slicing and the transfer bounds; its preceding one-step estimates remain inputs.

  3. Two construction routes. No identification of the families from III.13 and III.14, or transfer of III.13.5 to the III.14 family, is established here. A common witness satisfying both lists would require a separate argument.

  4. Moving-frame estimates. The basis construction and its comparison with the free Gram form belong to VII.1/VII.3. Lemma 4.20 uses those estimates; their proofs are not reproduced here.

  5. The penalty. Its role as the Gaussian block-spin coefficient is fixed by the kernel choices. Its precise normalization relative to Balaban's parameter \(a\) has not been verified.

  6. Other reports. Reports.ultraviolet, Oasis.fruition give additional reports. They are not needed for the assembly of III.13.1–III.13.4. The same applies to the offset and analytic-tuning test wrappers and the separate fixed-volume existence theorem.

← III.12 Bounds uniform in the volume and convergence as the spacing tends to zero (notes)Part III·Unit outlineIII.14 The construction run: flat representations and the ultraviolet rate (notes) →