Home·The theorem·The proof in one reading·Architecture·Units·Manuscript·Glossary·FAQ·Work items·Data·Method·Provenance·Changes
← III.2 Choosing the constants: the order of choice and the RG schedule (notes)Part III·Unit outlineIII.4 Gaussian integration: change of Gaussian sector, determinants, window law (notes) →

III.3. Free lattice kernels and covariances — detailed notes

Contents

1. What this unit proves 2

2. What it uses 8

3. Strategy 9

4. Steps 10

4.1 Filters and histories 10

4.2 Explicit metric data 11

4.3 Transfer kernels of one flight 12

4.4 The defect and the amendment 14

4.5 The catalogue 15

4.6 Along a schedule: pre-repair, repair, output 15

4.7 All tori 17

4.8 Free covariance of the curvature (III.3.6) 17

4.9 Calculus lemmas (III.3.7) 18

4.10 Auxiliary results 18

5. Where the difficulty lies 19

6. Notation 20

7. What remains unexplained 21

The full account of unit III.3: every proposition with its proof sketch, checked against the Lean in two rounds and edited. The condensed outline and the map of the Lean are on the unit page.

Unit page · All units · Overview

Part: III, Ultraviolet construction (renormalization group). Lean: YM/Next/FREE_KERNELS/ (5,450 lines), YM/MultiNext/SIGNED_SOURCE_CONTINUATION/ (1,674), YM/Further/FREE_COVARIANCE_KP/ (924), YM/UVNext/PRICED_KERNELS/ (533), YM/Further/CORRECTED_LIFT_COEFFICIENTS/ (248), YM/Push/CUTOFF_PROJECTORS/ (139), YM/ProofPorts/GRID_RENEWED_RESERVES/ (30). Size: 8,998 lines in the main-theorem closure.

Conventions.

1. What this unit proves

The unit computes the Gaussian part of the block-spin step of III.1 in closed form, for every history of steps. It proves three things about it:

The constants are fixed before the block sizes (Proposition III.3.1). Positivity of the rolled kernel requires the lower bound \(L \geqslant b_j\).

The package also contains:

The identities of one step. Fix a step with tori \(\Lambda_f, \Lambda_c\), \(f = cL\). Let \(Q : \Omega^1 (\Lambda_f) \to \Omega^1 (\Lambda_c)\) be the linearised block average of III.1: a weighted average, over a \(J\)-fold smoothing patch, of line integrals of the fine 1-form along \(L\)-link paths.

Metric data on a level is a quintuple \(\mathcal{B}= (D, D^{- 1}, H, H^{- 1}, R)\) of kernels on 2-forms: a diagonal multiplier, its inverse, a metric, its inverse, and a root. With the direct coefficient \(c\) of the level's clip, set

\(\displaystyle V = (\sqrt{c} \hspace{0.17em} 1, \hspace{0.17em} R) : \Omega^2 \to \Omega^2 \oplus \Omega^2 .\)

Then \(V^{\ast} V = c \hspace{0.17em} 1 + R^{\ast} R = H\) and \(\langle dA, H \hspace{0.17em} dA \rangle = |V \hspace{0.17em} dA|^2\).

Transfer kernels are \(\mathcal{U}= (W, T, M_f, M_n, O)\) with:

With fine data \((\mathcal{B}, V)\) and coarse data \((\mathcal{B}', V')\), the identities are:

What the identities mean:

Proposition III.3.1 (catalogue fixed before the block sizes). Let \(K\) be a kernel choice. There are numbers \(\alpha_j > 0\), \(\eta_j > 0\), \(\Omega_j \in \mathbb{R}\), \(\lambda_j \geqslant 0\) (amendments), \(\gamma_j > 0\) (clip bounds) and \(b_j \in \mathbb{N}\) (block thresholds), \(j \in \mathbb{N}\), depending only on \(K\), with the following properties.

(a) Metric data of a history. Let \(j \geqslant 4\), let the clip have direct coefficient \(c \leqslant \gamma_j\), and let \(v\) be a history of stage index \(j\). Then there is metric data \((D, D^{- 1}, H, H^{- 1}, R)\) such that:

(b) One step. Let \(j, t \geqslant 4\) with \(t \in \{j, j - 1\}\), and let \(P\) be a flight of index \((j, t)\): odd block size \(L \geqslant 3\) and fine history of index \(j\). Then:

Status: theorem, with no hypothesis beyond the kernel choice. It uses III.6's square-root theorem to construct \(R\). The catalogue does not depend on \(G\). Lean: Catalog, pledges, BottomQuote, HopQuote, Mag, Defined, Floor, Donate, Funds.

Proposition III.3.2 (free kernels along an admissible schedule). Let \(G\) be a gauge group and \(K\) a kernel choice. There is a catalogue \((\alpha, \Omega, \eta, \lambda, \gamma, b)\) as in III.3.1 with the following property. For every sheet \(\mathfrak{S}\) with kernel \(K\) (the pre-\(L\) constants, III.2) there is a second table \((\alpha'_j, \Omega'_j, \eta_j)\) such that the conclusion below holds.

Let \(A\) be an RG trajectory with kernel \(K\) and the stage profile of \(\mathfrak{S}\), satisfying the credit condition:

Then, simultaneously for all \(N \geqslant 0\) and \(0 \leqslant i \leqslant N\), there are two families of metric data and transfer kernels: a pre-repair family \(\textsf{M} = (\mathcal{B}^{N, i}, \mathcal{U}^{N, i})\) and an output family \(\textsf{H} = (\mathcal{B}^{N, i}, \tilde{\mathcal{U}}^{N, i})\). They have the same metric data and the same \(W, T\), and satisfy:

  1. Explicit formulas. \(\mathcal{B}^{N, i}\) is the metric data of III.3.1(a) for the history of level \(i\) in mesh \(N\), with amendment \(\lambda_{J (i)}\). That history is the composite of the stage hops of steps \(N - 1, \ldots, i\), starting from the empty history at level \(N\). \(W^{N, i}, T^{N, i}\) are the explicit transfer kernels of the flight of step \(i\), of index \((J (i + 1), J (i))\).

  2. Pre-repair conditions (\(\textsf{M}\)).

  3. Output conditions (\(\textsf{H}\)), with the second table.

Status: theorem. The inputs F06–F09 (III.6) are discharged inside the proof. For trajectories with the stated kernel and profile, the additional hypothesis is the credit condition. The variant before_paid (assigned to III.4) replaces it by:

III.9 builds the sheet so that these hold: its floors are exactly \(b\) and its clip coefficients are \(\leqslant \gamma\) (housing). The variant also lets the second table be computed from a preliminary sheet \(\mathfrak{S}\) and used for any later sheet \(\mathfrak{S}'\), provided \(\mathfrak{S}'\) has the same direct clip coefficients, the same kernel, a drift at least as large, and logarithmic parameter size at least as large.

Lean: retained_support; conditions Present, Craft.Rack, Bid.Retained, Horizon.Suffices, Bid.Sworn, Credit; discharge credit_from_sheet, Willing.

Proposition III.3.3 (identities on every torus). Let a family satisfy the output conditions of III.3.2(3) for some table. For every \(N\), \(m < N\) and positive sides \(c, f\) with \(f = cL_m\), (D1)–(D4) and (R1)–(R6) hold, with the same kernels and the clips of levels \(m + 1, m\). The diagonal identities follow by rigidity (III.10, panes). They also follow from the explicit formulas when the family realises them (universal_diagonal). Given the diagonal identities, the roll identities follow from the output conditions by the same rigidity argument. Status: theorem. Lean: complete_roll, Towers.Diagonal, Towers.Roll, Inputs. Used in III.10.

Proposition III.3.4 (positivity of the rolled 3-form kernel). Fix a kernel choice \(K\) and \(j, t \geqslant 4\). There are \(C_0, B > 0\), depending only on \((K, j, t)\), with the following property. For every coarse amendment \(\lambda \geqslant C_0\) and fine amendment \(\mu \geqslant 0\) there are \(\eta, \sigma, \Omega > 0\) such that, for every flight \(P\) of index \((j, t)\):

Status: theorem. Lean: Flight.frontier, Flight.absorb_before.

Proposition III.3.5 (line and box filters). For positive integers \(L, M\), define the uncentred line average below; for odd \(L, M\), also define the centred line and box averages:

\(\displaystyle \text{plank}_M (z) = M^{- 1} \sum_{|s| \leqslant (M - 1) / 2} e^{isz}, \qquad \text{rail}_M (z) = M^{- 1} \sum_{s = 0}^{M - 1} e^{isz}, \qquad a_L (p) = \prod_a \text{plank}_L (p_a)\)

(centred line average, uncentred line average, box average). Then:

(a) \(\text{rail}_L (Mz) \hspace{0.17em} \text{rail}_M (z) = \text{rail}_{LM} (z)\) for all positive \(L, M\), and \(\text{plank}_L (Mz) \hspace{0.17em} \text{plank}_M (z) = \text{plank}_{LM} (z)\) for odd \(L, M\). For odd \(M\), \(\text{plank}_M\) is even, \(2 \pi\)-periodic and real on \(\mathbb{R}\).

(b) \(| \text{plank}_M (z) |, | \text{rail}_M (z) | \leqslant e^{M | \text{Im} \hspace{0.17em} z|}\).

(c) There are absolute constants \(c_{\ast}, c_1 > 0\) such that \(| \text{rail}_M (z) | \geqslant c_{\ast}\) for complex \(z\) with \(M |z| \leqslant 3 \pi / 2\), and \(| \text{plank}_M (z) | \geqslant e^{- c_1 M / L}\) for real \(z\), \(M \leqslant L\) and \(L |z| \leqslant 3 \pi / 2\).

(d) There is an absolute \(B\) such that \(| \text{rail}_L ((q_{\ell})_a) |, | \text{plank}_L ((q_{\ell})_a) | \leqslant B / (1 + | \ell_a |)\). This holds for odd \(L\), every \(p\) in the complex cube \(\{| \text{Re} \hspace{0.17em} p_a | < \tfrac{5 \pi}{4}, | \text{Im} \hspace{0.17em} p_a | < \tfrac{\pi}{4} \}\), every alias \(\ell\) and every \(a\).

Status: theorem. Lean: plank, rail, area, plank_bind, rail_bind, plank_height, rail_lower, principal_plank, alias_rail.

Proposition III.3.6 (free covariance of the curvature). Call a real 2-form kernel \(f\) firm with constants \((\alpha, \Omega, \eta)\) if \(f \in \mathcal{S} (\alpha, \Omega)\), \(\hat{f} (0) = 1\), and \(\eta | \omega |^2 \leqslant \langle \omega, f_n \omega \rangle \leqslant \Omega | \omega |^2\) for every real cochain on every torus. Symmetry is not required. Fix \(\alpha, \eta > 0\) and \(\Omega \in \mathbb{R}\), and let \(U = \{p \in \mathbb{R}^4 \setminus \{0\}: |p_a | < 3 \pi / 2\}\). For \(p \in U\) define:

(a) There is \(b > 0\), depending only on \(\alpha, \Omega, \eta\), such that \(\text{Re} \hspace{0.17em} \langle x, \Phi_f (p) x \rangle \geqslant b |p|^2 |x|^2\) for every firm \(f\), \(p \in U\) and complex 1-form \(x\).

(b) For every \(n \in \mathbb{N}\) there is \(C_n \geqslant 0\), depending only on \(n, \alpha, \Omega, \eta\), such that, for all firm \(f\) and \(p \in U\), \(\|D^n G_f (p)\| \leqslant C_n |p|^{- n}\) and \(\|D^n (G_f - G_{\infty}) (p)\| \leqslant C_n |p|^{1 - n}\).

(c) If \(f\) is a scalar kernel with \(\sum_x e^{\alpha |x|_1} |f (x) | \leqslant \Omega\), then \(\hat{f}\) is \(C^{\infty}\) on \(\mathbb{R}^4\) and \(\|D^n \hat{f} (p)\| \leqslant A_n \Omega\) for every \(p\), where \(A_0 = 1\) and \(A_n = (n / \alpha)^n\) for \(n \geqslant 1\). Here \(D^n\) is the full \(n\)th Fréchet derivative, with its multilinear operator norm; this notation also applies to (b).

Status: theorems. Part (b) is used in III.11. Lean: tank_full, gem_quote, radial_prices, Firm, fuel, garnet, pearl.

Proposition III.3.7 (calculus lemmas for the nonlinear step). These do not concern free kernels; they are consumed in III.10 and III.2.

(a) Discrete Taylor expansion with scaled bounds. Let \(b, k \in \mathbb{N}\) with \(k \leqslant b\). There is \(C = C (b, k) \geqslant 1\) with the following property. Let \(L \geqslant 1\), \(M \geqslant 0\), and let \(p : \mathbb{Z}^4 \to E\) (\(E\) a real normed vector space) satisfy \(\| \nabla_u p (x)\| \leqslant ML^{- 1 - |u|} (1 + L^{- 1} |x|_1)^b\) for all words \(u\) of forward differences with \(|u| \leqslant k\). Then the Newton pieces \(P_i (x) = \sum_{| \nu | = i} \binom{x}{\nu} \nabla^{\nu} p (0)\), of degree at most \(i\), satisfy \(\|P_i (x)\| \leqslant CML^{- 1 - i} (1 + |x|_1)^b\) for \(i < k\), and the remainder satisfies \(\|p (x) - \sum_{i < k} P_i (x)\| \leqslant CML^{- 1 - k} (1 + |x|_1)^b\).

(b) Weighted Taylor coefficients. Let \(d \in \mathbb{N}\) and let \(f : E \to F\) be \(C^d\) at \(0\) between real normed vector spaces. Let \(p_v : E \to E\) (\(v \in V\) finite) be continuous linear maps with \(\sum_v p_v = 1\), and let \(Y_v \geqslant 1\) be integers. Suppose that for every \(z\) the function \(t \mapsto f (\sum_v t^{Y_v} p_v z)\) has vanishing derivatives of orders \(0, \ldots, d\) at \(0\). Then \(D^m f (0) (x_1, \ldots, x_m) = 0\) whenever there are integers \(k_i \geqslant 1\) with \(\sum_i k_i \leqslant d\) and \(p_v (x_i) = 0\) for every \(v\) with \(Y_v > k_i\).

(c) Moments of local gauge-invariant functions. Fix \(b, d \in \mathbb{N}\) with \(b \leqslant d\), a torus \(\Lambda_n\) with \(n \geqslant 2\), an anchor \(o\), and a finite support \(X\) satisfying \(10 \hspace{0.17em} \text{dist} (x, o) < n\) for every \(x \in X\), where \(\text{dist}\) is the torus \(\ell^{\infty}\) distance. Let \(u : \text{Config} (G, \Lambda_n) \to \mathbb{C}\) be gauge invariant and depend only on links whose two endpoints lie in \(X\), with \(u \circ \exp\) of class \(C^b\) at \(0\). For every radial polynomial connection jet \(J\) through weight \(d\), let \(U_{J, o} (t)\) be its link holonomies at scale \(t\), based at \(o\): a homogeneous connection component of degree \(r - 1\) has weight \(r\), \(2 \leqslant r \leqslant d\), and is multiplied by \(t^r\). Assume \(\frac{d^k}{dt^k} u (U_{J, o} (t)) |_{t = 0} = 0\) for every \(J\) and \(0 \leqslant k \leqslant b\). For any \(m \in \mathbb{N}\), \(p_1, \ldots, p_m \geqslant 1\) with \(\sum_i p_i \leqslant b\), and link fields \(w_i\) whose values on those links are polynomials of degree at most \(p_i - 1\) in the centred lift of the initial site relative to \(o\), one has \(D^m (u \circ \exp) (0) (w_1, \ldots, w_m) = 0\). Values of \(w_i\) on other links are unrestricted.

(d) Radial decomposition. Let \(j \in \mathbb{N}\) and let \(Q_a : \mathbb{R}^4 \to \mathfrak{g}\) (\(a = 1, \ldots, 4\)) be homogeneous polynomials of degree \(j + 1\). Then \(Q_a = K_a + \partial_a r\), where \(r = (j + 2)^{- 1} \sum_a x_a Q_a\) is homogeneous of degree \(j + 2\), and \(K\) is homogeneous of degree \(j + 1\) with \(\sum_a x_a K_a = 0\) (the Fock–Schwinger condition).

(e) Small-field condition along rays. There is \(C = C (G) > 0\) with the following property. Let \(0 \leqslant b \leqslant 1\), \(\tau \geqslant Cb^2\), and let \(v\) be Lie-algebra link variables with \(|v_x | \leqslant b\) on all links within distance \(5\) of \(Y\). If every plaquette touching \(Y\) has holonomy within chord distance \(\tau\) of \(1\) for the configuration \(\exp (v)\), then the same plaquette bounds hold for \(\exp (sv)\), \(0 \leqslant s \leqslant 1\).

Status: theorems. Lean: capital, cancel, converse, wiped, locale, strings.

2. What it uses

From other units.

Standard mathematics.

Imported constants and assumptions.

3. Strategy

The Gaussian block-spin problem is solved in Fourier space. Iterating the block average and its independent noise gives a diagonal 1-form covariance symbol. Minimising its precision over gauge directions gives the effective form \(d^{\ast} Dd\) by Lagrange's identity. The background-field map \(W\) and curvature transfer \(T\) are then explicit alias sums satisfying (D1)–(D4).

Uniform decay follows from the filters. A stage-\(J\) box filter gives \(\prod_a (1 + | \ell_a |)^{- J}\) alias decay, leaving \(J - 2\) fine differences summable. Along a history, successive dilation ratios decrease at least geometrically by \(1 / 3\), so the extra filter products and accumulated noise stay uniformly bounded. Before estimating inverse symbols, the principal-alias poles are cancelled. The remaining denominators are bounded below at real momenta and hence on a thinner complex cube. These constants depend on the kernel choice and stage, uniformly in history length and block sizes.

The inverse-metric defect factors through \(d_2\) as \({X'}^{\ast} CX'\), where \(X' = d_2 {D'}^{- 1}\) and \(C\) need not be positive. Amending the fine and coarse inverse metrics leaves their quadratic forms on potentials unchanged and replaces \(C\) by \(C + \lambda_t - \lambda_j S^{\ast} S\). The squared 3-form transfer satisfies \(S^{\ast} S = O (L^{- 2})\), including the sum over fine residues. Choose the coarse amendments first, then require \(\lambda_j B / L^2 \leqslant 1\). The resulting positive defect yields \(M_f, M_n, O\) and (R1)–(R6) through III.6 and the repair theorem of III.10. The repair constants also depend on the sheet's direct clip coefficients. Rigidity extends the schedule identities to all tori.

4. Steps

4.1 Filters and histories

Lemma 4.1 (filter algebra). This is III.3.5(a). Sketch: \(M \hspace{0.17em} \text{rail}_M (z) (e^{iz} - 1) = e^{iMz} - 1\); apply it twice and cancel \(e^{iz} - 1\) when nonzero. If \(e^{iz} = 1\), every uncentred average is \(1\). For the centred filter, the centring phases add up, since \(M \hspace{0.17em} \frac{L - 1}{2} + \frac{M - 1}{2} = \frac{LM - 1}{2}\). Lean: rail_bind, plank_bind.

Lemma 4.2 (size of filters). This is III.3.5(b)–(d). Sketch:

Lean: plank_height, rail_height, rail_lower, plank_lower, principal_plank, alias_rail.

Lemma 4.3 (histories). A history of stage index \(j\) is either empty, or a hop \((L, J)\) with \(j \leqslant J \leqslant j + 1\) and odd \(L \geqslant 3\), applied after a history of index \(J\). Its dilation \(M_v\) is the product of its block sizes. Its cumulative filter is defined by \(s_{\emptyset} = 1\) and \(s_{(L, J) \circ v} (p) = a_L (M_v p)^J s_v (p)\). Equivalently, \(s_v = a_{M_v}^{\hspace{0.17em} j} e_v\), where \(e_v\) is a product of box filters at the hops where the index drops. Then:

Here \(C_j, c_j\) do not depend on \(v\), that is, on the number of hops or the block sizes. Sketch: After \(k\) further hops, a hop of dilation \(M'\) is evaluated at the momentum scaled by \(M' / M_v \leqslant 3^{- k}\). Lemma 4.2 gives factors \(e^{\pm CM' / M_v}\), and these products converge. The factor \(a_{M_v}^j\) gives the alias decay by 4.2(d); the geometric product bounds the extra factors. Lean: Train, Train.smooth, Train.bind, Train.smooth_upper, Train.smooth_lower.

4.2 Explicit metric data

Lemma 4.4 (auxiliary 1-form covariance symbols). Fix \(\kappa > 0\) and a history \(v\) of dilation \(M\). For a direction \(a\), let \(\chi_{v, a} (p) = s_v (p) \hspace{0.17em} \text{rail}_M (p_a)\). For \(p \in \mathcal{C}_{\pi / 4}^{\mathbb{R}} \setminus \{0\}\) and \(q_{\ell} = (p + 2 \pi \ell) / M\), define

\(\displaystyle D_a (p) = M^{- 2} \sum_{\ell} \frac{| \chi_{v, a} (q_{\ell}) |^2}{| \tau (q_{\ell}) |^2} + \kappa^{- 1} \sum_{v'} M_{v'}^{- 2} \sum_{\ell'} | \chi_{v', a} (q'_{\ell'}) |^2 .\)

The second sum runs over the proper final segments \(v'\) of \(v\) (the last \(k\) hops, \(0 \leqslant k < \sharp v\)), with \(q'_{\ell'} = (p + 2 \pi \ell') / M_{v'}\). For the empty history, \(D_a = | \tau |^{- 2}\). The formula obeys the exact one-step recursion \(D'_a (p) = L^{- 2} \sum_{\ell} |a_L (q_{\ell})^j \text{rail}_L ((q_{\ell})_a) |^2 D_a (q_{\ell}) + \kappa^{- 1}\), which is the covariance recursion for an averaged field with independent noise. These singular symbols are used only away from zero; Lemma 4.6 constructs the regular 2-form symbols. Lean: Train.levelD, D_feedback, Train.levelNoise, feed. (definitions and covariance recursion proof read)

Lemma 4.5 (the diagonal). At the nonzero real momenta of Lemma 4.4, let \(\rho = \sum_a | \tau_a |^2 / D_a\) and \(D_{\mu \nu} = (\rho \hspace{0.17em} D_{\mu} D_{\nu})^{- 1}\); this is a multiplier diagonal in the plaquette orientation. Then, with \(F = \text{diag} (D_a)\),

\(\displaystyle \sigma_1^{\ast} D \hspace{0.17em} \sigma_1 = F^{- 1} - \rho^{- 1} F^{- 1} \tau \hspace{0.17em} \tau^{\ast} F^{- 1} .\)

So \(d^{\ast} Dd\) is the precision \(F^{- 1}\) minimised over gauge directions. For the empty history, \(D = 1\) (the Wilson quadratic form). Sketch: Lagrange's identity \(\sum_{\mu < \nu} w_{\mu} w_{\nu} | \tau_{\mu} x_{\nu} - \tau_{\nu} x_{\mu} |^2 = (\sum_a w_a | \tau_a |^2) (\sum_a w_a |x_a |^2) - | \sum_a w_a \bar{\tau}_a x_a |^2\), with \(w_a = D_a^{- 1}\). The weights and \(\rho\) are positive. Lean: rotor_law, pulse, vault, pink, blue, top_metric.

Lemma 4.6 (filled symbols, uniform analyticity). Fix \(\kappa > 0\). Away from \(p = 0\) in the real cube, the singular formulas become regular combinations. With \(| \tau_M |^2 = \sum_a M^2 |e^{ip_a / M} - 1|^2\):

\(\displaystyle D_a = \beta_a / | \tau_M |^2, \qquad \rho = | \tau_M |^4 h, \qquad D_{\mu \nu} = (h \hspace{0.17em} \beta_{\mu} \beta_{\nu})^{- 1} .\)

Here \(\beta_a\) is the principal term \(| \chi_{v, a} (p / M) |^2\) plus \(| \tau_M |^2\) times the non-principal and noise terms, and \(h\) is a rational combination of filters whose denominators stay nonzero on a sufficiently thin cube. The regular formulas give \(\beta_a (0) = h (0) = 1\). For each \(j \geqslant 4\) there are \(\theta, C, c > 0\), depending only on \(\kappa, j\), such that, for all histories of index \(j\), \(\beta_a\) and \(h\) are analytic and bounded by \(C\) on \(\mathcal{C}_{\theta}\), and \(| \beta_a |, |h| \geqslant c\) on \(\mathcal{C}_{\theta}^{\mathbb{R}}\). Hence \(D\) and \(D^{- 1}\) lie in a common \(\mathcal{S} (\alpha, \Omega)\), uniformly over histories of index \(j\). Sketch:

Lean: Train.bulb, Train.bend, Train.pole_split, Train.lift_bend, Train.recover_rho, Train.bulb_firm, Train.bend_firm, heart_banked, Moderate.

Lemma 4.7 (amended metric). Fix \(\kappa > 0\), \(j \geqslant 4\) and \(\lambda \geqslant 0\). For each history of index \(j\), let

\(\displaystyle H^{- 1} = D^{- 1} + \lambda \hspace{0.17em} X^{\ast} X, \quad X = d_2 D^{- 1}, \qquad \mathcal{T}_{\lambda} = (1 + \lambda \hspace{0.17em} Xd_2^{\ast})^{- 1} \text{on 3-forms} .\)

Then on every torus: \(HH^{- 1} = 1\), \(Hd = Dd\), \(XH =\mathcal{T}_{\lambda} d_2\), and \(H, \mathcal{T}_{\lambda}\) are symmetric. Moreover \(\hat{H} (0) = 1\), and \(H, H^{- 1}, \mathcal{T}_{\lambda}, \mathcal{T}_{\lambda}^{- 1}\) have strip bounds and two-sided bounds at real momenta, with constants depending only on \(\kappa, j, \lambda\). The amendment changes \(H\) only away from exact 2-forms, and leaves \(d^{\ast} Hd = d^{\ast} Dd\) unchanged. Sketch:

Lean: pledge, amend, bail, treble, obligations, pledge_warm, insurance, forced_amend.

Lemma 4.8 (metric data of every history; III.3.1(a)). Let \(\kappa > 0\), \(\lambda \geqslant 0\), \(j \geqslant 4\). There are \(\gamma, \sigma, \eta, C > 0\) with the following property. For every clip with \(c \leqslant \gamma\) and every history of index \(j\), the explicit \(D, D^{- 1}, H, H^{- 1}\), together with a positive symmetric square root \(R\) of \(H - c \hspace{0.17em} 1\), satisfy III.3.1(a) with amendment \(\lambda\) and bounds \(\sigma, \eta, C\). These constants depend only on \(\kappa, j, \lambda\). Sketch:

Lean: bid_bed, Defined, full_cover, low_ceiling, sworn_metric.

4.3 Transfer kernels of one flight

A flight of index \((j, t)\) consists of an odd block size \(L \geqslant 3\), a fine history \(v\) of index \(j\), and the coarse history (hop \((L, j)\) after \(v\)) of index \(t \in \{j - 1, j\}\).

Lemma 4.9 (alias symbols and derivative bounds). Fix \(\kappa > 0\) and \(j, t \geqslant 4\). There are \(\theta, \alpha, C > 0\), depending only on \(\kappa, j, t\), such that the following holds for every flight of index \((j, t)\). Its explicit \(W\) and \(T\) are cross kernels; at this stage \(M_f = M_n = O = 0\). Their fibre at coarse momentum \(p\) and fine residue \(r\) is

\(\displaystyle L^{- e} \sum_{\ell} e^{iq_{\ell} \cdot r} w_e (p, \ell), \qquad e = 1 (W), \quad e = 2 (T),\)

with explicit per-alias symbols built from the filters and from \(\beta_a, h\) of both histories. At the harmonic point \(w_e (0, 0) = 1\) and \(w_e (0, \ell) = 0\) for \(\ell \ne 0\). Each \(w_e (\cdot, \ell)\) is analytic on \(\mathcal{C}_{\theta}\) and bounded by \(C \prod_a (1 + | \ell_a |)^{- j}\), uniformly over flights. Hence, for words \(u\) with \(|u| \leqslant j - 2\), \(\nabla_u W \in \mathcal{S} (\alpha, CL^{- 1 - |u|})\) and \(\nabla_u T \in \mathcal{S} (\alpha, CL^{- 2 - |u|})\). Sketch: A fine difference in direction \(a\) multiplies the alias term by \(e^{i (q_{\ell})_a} - 1 = O ((1 + | \ell |) / L)\). The sum \(\sum_{\ell} (1 + | \ell |)^{|u|} \prod_a (1 + | \ell_a |)^{- j}\) converges for \(|u| \leqslant j - 2\). In other words, the order \(j\) of the smoothing pays for \(j - 2\) derivatives. Decay is measured on the coarse lattice, so the fine-lattice rate is \(\alpha / L\). Lean: Flight.duo, Flight.pilot_cost, Flight.ahead_cost, Flight.wire_budget, secure_both, Secured.propels.

Lemma 4.10 (exact identities for one flight). Fix a flight of index \((j, t)\) with \(t \geqslant 4\), a kernel choice \(K\), and any pair of tori with \(f = cL\). Then (D1)–(D4) hold for:

Sketch:

Lean: Flight.tangent, diagonal, Flight.scaled_tri, hinge_transport, ZeroAlias.lean, pilot, wire, script_main, script_cross, script_dual. (proof read, including the nonzero-alias algebra and harmonic point)

4.4 The defect and the amendment

Lemma 4.11 (unamended defect). In the setting of 4.10, let \({\mathcal{V}= D'}^{- 1} - T^{\ast} D^{- 1} T - \kappa^{- 1} dd^{\ast}\) on \(\Omega^2 (\Lambda_c)\). Then \(D' \mathcal{V}D'\) is symmetric, and \(D' \mathcal{V}D' d = 0\) on every torus. Consequently there is an explicit symmetric 3-form kernel \(C\), decaying uniformly over flights of index \((j, t)\), with

\(\displaystyle \mathcal{V}= (d_2 {D'}^{- 1})^{\ast} \hspace{0.17em} C \hspace{0.17em} (d_2 {D'}^{- 1}) \quad \text{on every torus.}\)

Sketch:

Lean: Flight.gap, Flight.dep_zero, Double.duplex, Flight.fund, Flight.banked_dollars. Quantitative control: duplex_stock.

Lemma 4.12 (amended defect: identity (Δ)). In the setting of Lemma 4.10, take fine amendment \(\mu \geqslant 0\) and coarse amendment \(\lambda \geqslant 0\). Then (Δ) holds on every pair of tori, with \(P =\mathcal{P}_{\mu, \lambda}\) where

\(\displaystyle \mathcal{P}_{\mu, \lambda} =\mathcal{T}_{\lambda}^{\ast} \left( C + \lambda \hspace{0.17em} 1 - \mu \hspace{0.17em} S^{\ast} S \right) \mathcal{T}_{\lambda} .\)

Here \(S\) is the 3-form transfer kernel of the flight, with \(S \hspace{0.17em} d_2 {D'}^{- 1} = d_2 D^{- 1} T\), and \(S^{\ast} S\) has strip bounds \(O (L^{- 2})\). Sketch: Write \(X = d_2 D^{- 1}\) and \(X' = d_2 {D'}^{- 1}\). Then

\(\displaystyle {H'}^{- 1} - T^{\ast} H^{- 1} T - \kappa^{- 1} dd^{\ast} {=\mathcal{V}+ \lambda X'}^{\ast} X' - \mu \hspace{0.17em} T^{\ast} X^{\ast} XT.\)

Since \(XT = SX'\), the last term is \({- X'}^{\ast} (\mu S^{\ast} S) X'\); with Lemma 4.11 the whole expression is \({X'}^{\ast} (C + \lambda - \mu S^{\ast} S) X'\). Conjugate by \(H'\) and use \(X' H' =\mathcal{T}_{\lambda} d_2\) (Lemma 4.7). Lean: Flight.rebased, Flight.rollFunds, Flight.render, Flight.intake, Flight.sale, Flight.netted, check_bleep.

Lemma 4.13 (positivity; III.3.4). The constants and bounds of III.3.4 hold uniformly over flights of the fixed index \((j, t)\). Sketch:

Lean: Flight.absorb_before, Flight.frontier.

4.5 The catalogue

Lemma 4.14 (III.3.1). For every kernel choice \(K\), a catalogue satisfying III.3.1 exists. Sketch:

Lean: buys, pledges.

4.6 Along a schedule: pre-repair, repair, output

Lemma 4.15 (pre-repair family). Fix a catalogue of III.3.1 and a trajectory with its kernel, satisfying the credit condition. Define:

This family satisfies the pre-repair conditions of III.3.2(2):

Lean: shelves, stageHop, location, destination.

Lemma 4.16 (repair; III.10 with III.6's theorems). For every sheet and every table \(X\) there is a table \(X'\) with the following property. Every pre-repair family for \(X\) (for a trajectory with the sheet's profile and kernel) has a repaired family with the same metric data and the same \(W, T\), which satisfies the output conditions for \(X'\). For step \(i\) the construction is:

  1. F06 applied to \(P\) from (Δ): a kernel \(P_1\) with two-sided bounds at real momenta, a strip bound, and \(d_2^{\ast} P_1 d_2 = d_2^{\ast} Pd_2\) on every torus.

  2. F07: a symmetric decaying square root, \(P_1 = P_2^{\ast} P_2\).

  3. F08: kernels with the same \(W, T\) and

    \(\displaystyle M_f = VH^{- 1} T \hspace{0.17em} {V'}^{\ast}, \qquad M_n = \kappa^{- 1 / 2} d^{\ast} {V'}^{\ast}, \qquad O = \left( 1 - \Pi, P_2 \hspace{0.17em} d_2 {H'}^{- 1} {V'}^{\ast} \right), \qquad \Pi = V' {H'}^{- 1} {V'}^{\ast},\)

    with the strip and derivative bounds of III.3.2(3). The constants depend only on \(X\), \(\kappa\) and the sheet's direct clip coefficients.

  4. F09 (algebra) gives (R1)–(R6). Since \({V'}^{\ast} V' = H'\), \(\Pi\) is the orthogonal projection onto the range of \(V'\). Then:

The second table depends on the sheet only through the direct clip coefficients, which enter \(V, V'\). It can be chosen with \(\alpha'_j \leqslant \alpha_j\), \(\Omega'_j \geqslant \Omega_j\) and unchanged \(\eta_j\). Lean: Bid.pinning, F06, F07, F08, F09, Replaces. (repair proof and F08–F09 proofs read)

Lemma 4.17 (III.3.2 and its variant). The catalogue and repair construction give the families and constants asserted in III.3.2, including its preliminary-sheet variant. Sketch: Take the catalogue (4.14), then the second table from the repair theorem with III.6's theorems (4.16), then the pre-repair family (4.15), then its repair. The explicit formulas and the symmetry carry over because the metric data and \(W, T\) are unchanged. In the variant, the payment record of the schedule turns sheet-level bounds into (C1)–(C2). A preliminary sheet is handled by re-running the construction for a copy of the trajectory with the preliminary profile; this preserves the histories and the direct clip coefficients. Lean: retained_support, retained_presents, before_paid, credit_from_sheet.

4.7 All tori

Lemma 4.18 (rigidity of decaying kernels). Suppose two finite sums of products of decaying kernels, or of cross kernels of the same block size, define equal matrices on tori \(\Lambda_{c_k}\) (respectively on pairs \((c_k, c_k L)\)) with \(c_k \to \infty\). Then they are equal on every torus (pair). Sketch: Sums and products of decaying kernels are decaying kernels, so each side is a single kernel. A summable kernel is the limit of its periodisations as the period tends to infinity. Dominated convergence justifies this coefficient limit; the schedule sides of each fixed step tend to infinity. Lean: entry_limit, Echo.all, Echo.allAcross, Echo.Sound, Echo.schedule_sides.

Lemma 4.19 (III.3.3). Every output family of III.3.2 satisfies (D1)–(D4) and (R1)–(R6) on every torus pair of the same block ratio. Sketch:

Lean: complete_roll, orthogonal_iff, panes, universal_diagonal.

4.8 Free covariance of the curvature (III.3.6)

Lemma 4.20 (lower bound). The coercivity bound of III.3.6(a) holds uniformly over firm kernels. Sketch:

Lean: blade_id, ion, real_price, tank_full.

Lemma 4.21 (smooth symbols). This is III.3.6(c). Sketch: Differentiate the Fourier series termwise and use \(|y|_1^n \leqslant A_n e^{\alpha |y|_1}\), with \(A_n\) as in III.3.6(c). Lean: radial_prices.

Lemma 4.22 (comparison with the continuum). This is III.3.6(b). Let \(S^k (U)\) be the class of families with \(\|D^n g\| \leqslant C_n |p|^{k - n}\) on \(U\), uniformly over the family. Sums preserve a fixed order, products add orders, and inversion reverses the order when the rescaled matrix has a uniform coercivity bound. Sketch:

Lean: gem_quote, Weight, Value. (proof read, including the symbol-class product and inverse estimates)

4.9 Calculus lemmas (III.3.7)

Lemma 4.23 (nonlinear calculus). The statements of III.3.7 hold under their respective hypotheses. Sketch:

Lean: see III.3.7; Maps, covers, attenuation, testLinks. (proof read for (a)–(e), including the moment-space definition and transfer argument)

4.10 Auxiliary results

Three auxiliary packages concern local observables and equation spaces:

(statements read; the coefficient identity and jet-vanishing proofs read)

5. Where the difficulty lies

6. Notation

Written proof Lean (glossary) Meaning
\(R\), \(\hat{R}\), \(R_n\); \(\mathcal{S} (\alpha, \Omega)\) Row, Row.strip translation-invariant kernel, symbol, action on \(\Lambda_n\); strip bound
cross kernel Cross, installed coarse-to-fine kernel and its action
\(\text{plank}_M, \text{rail}_M, a_L, a_L^J\) plank, rail, area, massFilter line, box and \(J\)-fold box filters
history \(v\), dilation \(M_v\), filter \(s_v\) Train, Train.smooth finite history of block averages
flight of index \((j, t)\) Flight, Flight.land one step: block size, fine history, coarse history
\(D_a\); \(\rho\); \(\beta_a\), \(h\) Train.levelD, D_feedback; Train.rho; Train.bulb, Train.bend 1-form covariance; gauge factor; filled symbols
\(D\), \(D^{- 1}\) pink, blue diagonal 2-form multiplier, inverse
\(H^{- 1}\), \(H\); \(\mathcal{T}_{\lambda}\); \(\lambda\) pledge, amend; treble amended inverse metric, metric; 3-form factor; amendment
metric data \(\mathcal{B}\), \(V\) Bed, Bed.full, Floor \((D, D^{- 1}, H, H^{- 1}, R)\); \(V = (\sqrt{c} \hspace{0.17em} 1, R)\)
transfer kernels \((W, T, M_f, M_n, O)\) Towers (A0, T, mf, mn, o), Flight.duo background-field map, curvature transport, isometry blocks
(D1)–(D4); (R1)–(R6); (Δ) Towers.Diagonal, Inputs; Towers.Roll; Bleeps identities of one step
\(C\), \(S\), \(\mathcal{P}_{\mu, \lambda}\) Flight.fund, Flight.sale, Flight.rollFunds unamended 3-form defect, 3-form transport, rolled 3-form kernel
derivative bounds Donate, Towers.Deep \(\nabla_u\) bounds with \(L^{- 1 - \lvert u \rvert}\), \(L^{- 2 - \lvert u \rvert}\)
positive on \(\text{ran} \hspace{0.17em} \sigma_2\); two-sided at real momenta Reaches, Funds positivity conditions on 3-form kernels
kernel family; pre-repair; output conditions Horizon; Craft.Rack; Horizon.Suffices metric data and transfer kernels for all \((N, i)\)
explicit formulas; credit condition Present; Credit (III.3.2(1)); (C1)–(C2)
catalogue; price table Catalog; MapPrices constants fixed before \(L\)
hypercubic symmetry of \(d^{\ast} Hd\) Bid.Sworn invariance under signed permutations
firm kernel; \(\Phi_f\); \(G_f\); \(G_{\infty}\) Firm; fuel; garnet; pearl curvature covariance, lattice and continuum

7. What remains unexplained

  1. Gaussian interpretation and zero modes. Lemma 4.4 verifies the covariance recursion away from zero momentum. A measure-level derivation requires a stated treatment of gauge directions and harmonic modes; neither the auxiliary singular symbols nor III.1's action alone specifies that Gaussian measure. The identification with an iterated Feynman-gauge covariance remains probable.

  2. Change of Gaussian variables. The quadratic splitting in §1 follows from the identities. Its use as a change of integration variables, including null directions and determinants, belongs to III.4 and III.10 and is not established by this unit alone.

  3. Auxiliary spectral criterion. The finite-test hypotheses of the cited cutoff-projector criterion must be supplied at its point of use. Its statement does not assert that a trajectory satisfies them.

  4. Further proof detail. The analytic coefficient-extraction machinery underlying the strip bounds and the deeper positivity and square-root proofs F06–F07 are inputs here; their full proofs remain outside this account. The symbol-class calculations in Gem.lean and Weight.lean support the covariance comparison, but no position-space continuum limit or contact-term statement is asserted in III.3.6.

← III.2 Choosing the constants: the order of choice and the RG schedule (notes)Part III·Unit outlineIII.4 Gaussian integration: change of Gaussian sector, determinants, window law (notes) →