Home·The theorem·The proof in one reading·Architecture·Units·Manuscript·Glossary·FAQ·Work items·Data·Method·Provenance·Changes
← VII.4 Operator product expansion and contact extensions (notes)Part VII·Unit outlineVII.6 Scaling variants and fixed-field estimates (notes) →

VII.5. Asymptotic freedom of the running coupling — detailed notes

Contents

1. What this unit proves 1

2. What it uses 7

3. Strategy 9

4. Steps 10

4.1 The running coupling 10

4.2 Normalisation of the stress tensor (VII.5.4) 11

4.3 Exactly compatible frames (VII.5.5) 12

4.4 Finite-dimensional convergence (VII.5.6) 13

4.5 The classical stress-tensor algebra (VII.5.7) 13

5. Where the difficulty lies 14

6. Notation 15

7. What remains unexplained 15

The full account of unit VII.5: every proposition with its proof sketch, checked against the Lean in two rounds and edited. The condensed outline and the map of the Lean are on the unit page.

Unit page · All units · Overview

Part: VII, identification as Yang–Mills. Lean: YM/Pert/Asymptotics (the running coupling). Auxiliary declarations are in YM/Extra/WEAK_SCALING_ACTLAW (files Orientation, Criteria, Adjust, Analysis, Station), from YM/TraceExtension/Foundation (files Caps, Dilate), and one definition from YM/TraceExtension/Soot. Size: 232 lines in 43 declarations: 32 lines in Pert/Asymptotics (5 declarations), 162 in WEAK_SCALING_ACTLAW (24), 37 in TraceExtension/Foundation (13), 1 in TraceExtension/Soot (1).

1. What this unit proves

(A) The running coupling (5 declarations). The inverse squared coupling of the constructed renormalization-group trajectory grows logarithmically, uniformly in the lattice level and the volume (VII.5.1). This gives the regularity clause (Reg1) of the main theorem with slope \(b_{\ast} = 2 b_0\) (VII.5.2). It also gives the law \(g^2 \log (1 / a) \to 1 / (2 b_0)\) (VII.5.3).

(B) Auxiliary results (38 declarations).

Setting for (A).

The running clause (R) of the construction conditions reads: for every \(\varepsilon > 0\) there is \(m_0\) such that

\(\displaystyle | \beta_{N, p, m} - \hat{\beta}_m | \leqslant \varepsilon \hspace{0.17em} s_m \quad \text{for all } m \geqslant m_0, N \geqslant m, p \in \mathbb{N}.\)

Proposition VII.5.1 (uniform logarithmic growth of the inverse squared coupling). Let the family satisfy its construction conditions (II.2). For every \(\varepsilon > 0\) there is \(m_0 \geqslant 1\) such that

\(\displaystyle \left| \frac{\beta_{N, p, m}}{s_m} - 2 b_0 \right| < \varepsilon \qquad \text{for all } m \geqslant m_0, N \geqslant m, p \in \mathbb{N}.\)

Status: theorem. Of the construction conditions only (R) is used. Simplicity of \(\mathfrak{g}\) is not needed. Lean: YM.Pert.Asymptotics.zeroUp_bound, with b0 and b0_normalizes.

Corollary VII.5.2 ((Reg1) for the constructed family). Let \(\mathfrak{g}\) be simple and let the family satisfy its construction conditions. Then its Wilson family satisfies (Reg1) with slope \(b_{\ast} = 2 b_0 = 11 C_{\mathfrak{g}} / (24 \pi^2) > 0\): for every \(\varepsilon > 0\) there is \(N_0 \geqslant 1\) with

\(\displaystyle \left| \frac{\beta_{N, p}}{\log (1 / a_N)} - b_{\ast} \right| < \varepsilon \quad \text{for all } N \geqslant N_0 \text{ and all } p.\)

Status: theorem, proved in VIII.1 as the first clause of the regularity of the constructed family. It is VII.5.1 at \(m = N\), together with \(C_{\mathfrak{g}} > 0\) (I.1). This is how the main theorem uses part (A). The main theorem asserts the existence of a positive slope without specifying its value. Lean: YangMills.regular (running clause of YangMills.WilsonRegularity), via zeroUp_bound.

Proposition VII.5.3 (asymptotic freedom of the running coupling). Let \(\mathfrak{g}\) be simple and let the family satisfy its construction conditions. Let \((N_i)\) and \((k_i)\) be sequences of lattice levels and volume indices with \(i \leqslant N_i\) for all large \(i\). Then

\(\displaystyle \lim_{i \to \infty} g_{N_i, k_i, i} \hspace{0.17em} \sqrt{\log (1 / a_i)} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 b_0}}, \qquad \text{equivalently} \qquad g_{N_i, k_i, i}^2 \hspace{0.17em} \log (1 / a_i) \longrightarrow \frac{1}{2 b_0} .\)

Status: theorem; its square gives the second limit. No other declaration cites it. Lean: YM.Pert.Asymptotics.comparison, regulatorRun.

Setting for (B).

Proposition VII.5.4 (normalisation of the stress tensor along free-field scaling sequences). Fix the two hierarchies and the free Maxwell comparison data above. Let \(V\) be a derivative plan on \(S\) satisfying the inclusion and derivative axioms. Let \(J\) be symmetric, real and \(\Gamma_4\)-covariant, with \(\sum_a \partial^V_{4, a} J_{ab} = 0\) for every \(b\), and let \((J, p, Y)\) satisfy the local Ward identities.

(a) Suppose \(p_{4, a} = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial^V_{4, a}\) for \(a = 1, \ldots, 4\) and some \(c \in \mathbb{R}\). Then there are \(D, N, M \in \mathbb{N}\) and \(R_0 \geqslant 1\) such that \(c / \xi_k \to \kappa\) for every scaling sequence that tracks \((V, W, J)\) at a level \((n, d, j, R)\) with \(n \geqslant N\), \(d \geqslant D\), \(j \geqslant M\) and \(R \geqslant R_0\).

(b) If \(p \neq 0\), then \(J \neq 0\).

Status: theorems. Part (a) uses A04 and A05 (VI.1); part (b) requires only the hierarchy and local Ward identities. Lean: YM.Extra.WeakScaling.tracks_ratio, scale_limit, flux_nontrivial. Used in VI.2 by YM.Pert.ratio and YM.Pert.centered_line.

Proposition VII.5.5 (exactly compatible frames). Suppose \(S\) and its free comparison table carry Euclidean hierarchies. Let \(V\) and \(W\) be derivative plans on these tables satisfying the inclusion and orientation axioms.

(a) For every \(d\) there is a \(\mathbb{C}\)-linear map \(P_d : \mathcal{F}^{\circ}_{d + 1} \to \mathcal{F}^{\circ}_d\) with \(P_d \hspace{0.17em} \iota^W_{d \to d + 1} = 1\) that commutes with \(\Gamma_4\) and with conjugation.

(b) Let the \(P_d\) be as in (a), fix \(D \in \mathbb{N}\), and let \(A_d : \mathcal{F}^{\circ}_d \to \mathcal{F}_d\) be complex-linear isomorphisms for every \(d\). Define recursively

\(\displaystyle X_0 := A_0, \qquad X_{d + 1} := \iota^V_{d \to d + 1} \hspace{0.17em} X_d \hspace{0.17em} P_d + A_{d + 1} (1 - \iota^W_{d \to d + 1} P_d) .\)

Suppose that for every \(d \leqslant D\) the map \(A_d\) commutes with \(\Gamma_4\) and conjugation and maps unit to unit. Then:

(c) Let \(A^{(k)}_d\) be complex-linear isomorphisms such that, for every \(d < D\) and every \(v\),

\(\displaystyle (A^{(k)}_{d + 1})^{- 1} \hspace{0.17em} \iota^V_{d \to d + 1} \hspace{0.17em} A^{(k)}_d \hspace{0.17em} v \longrightarrow \iota^W_{d \to d + 1} v \qquad (k \to \infty) .\)

Let \(X^{(k)}\) be built from \(A^{(k)}\) as in (b). Then for every \(d \leqslant D\):

If the \(A^{(k)}_d\) also preserve the symmetries and units in (b), then, for all sufficiently large \(k\), the frames \(\tilde{X}^{(k)}_d\) are exactly compatible simultaneously in all degrees \(d \leqslant D\).

Status: theorem (finite-dimensional algebra and analysis). Lean: retraction, adjusted, Exact, adjusted_exact, Near, perturb_limit, eventually_unit, rotateChart, relative, Graded. Used in VII.1 by YM.SharpGram.Weak.Portfolio.tune_grades. Exact compatibility is also used in III.13 and VIII.1.

Proposition VII.5.6 (finite-dimensional convergence).

(a) Let \(f : E \to X\) be an injective linear map between finite-dimensional real normed spaces. If \(f (a_y) \to f (e)\) along a filter, then \(a_y \to e\).

(b) Let \(f_y, g : (\mathbb{R}^4)^n \to \mathbb{C}\) be continuous real-linear maps, and fix a filter on the index set of \(y\). If \(f_y (e_{i, a}) \to g (e_{i, a})\) at each of the \(4 n\) coordinate vectors, then \(f_y \to g\) in operator norm along that filter.

Status: theorem. Lean: norm_fit, norm_fit_deriv, components. Used in III.12 by YM.FullVolume.stretching.

Definition VII.5.7 (the classical stress-tensor algebra). Labels of degree \(d\) are gauge-invariant polynomials of weight at most \(d\) in radial Taylor coefficients at the base point. In the formulas below, \(F\) and \(\partial F\) denote the linear curls of the degree-0 and degree-1 Taylor coefficients used in the free Maxwell comparison. The curvature has weight 2 and each derivative adds 1 (II.1). \(\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle\) denotes the invariant inner product on \(\mathfrak{g}\). These are polynomial identities, before passing to the quotient by null fields; they do not multiply limiting fields at coincident points.

The definitions have two accompanying lemmas:

Status: definitions and two lemmas. Lean: square4, raw, momentum1, momentum2, momentum1_mem, momentum2_mem, momentum2_turn, basisV, bareVector (with mat3, proj3), shell_affine, sumPerm. The facts proved about these objects in VI.1 and VII.2 are listed in §4.5.

Definition VII.5.8 (sharp read-out bound). Fix the family, a nondecreasing control function \(K : \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{R}\) with \(K (j) \geqslant 1\) for every \(j\), a degree \(d\), stages \(\ell_d \leqslant k \leqslant N\), a volume index \(p\) and \(u \in \mathbb{R}\). Write \(\|c\|_1 := \sum_{\alpha} |c_{\alpha} |\) for the coefficient norm, and let \(P\) remove the unit coordinate. Here \(\ell_d\) is the reference stage fixed by the family. The predicate quantifies over every \(w \geqslant 0\) and all insertion presentations \(A_i\) with coefficient vectors \(c_i\), remainder costs \(q_i\), inserted densities \(\mathcal{D}_i\) and insertion points at the origin. They must satisfy:

The sharp read-out predicate is the assertion that every such chain satisfies

\(\displaystyle u \hspace{0.17em} \|c_k \|_1 \leqslant 4 (1 + n_k) w.\)

Status: definition. The admissibility and remainder conditions are those of Format, remBound; the complete chain conditions are Duet.Woke and direction. Lean: YM.MergeProof.Accent.SharpRead. Used by: YM.Trace.Terrace.Sceptre and the cost lemmas of VII.2.

2. What it uses

Inputs from other units.

Standard mathematics.

Imported constants and assumptions.

3. Strategy

Part (A). The coupling law follows from the one-step bound by summation and division by the logarithmic scale.

  1. Marginal flow (III.9). Blocking from stage \(m + 1\) to stage \(m\) gives \(\beta_{N, p, m} = \beta_{N, p, m + 1} - \kappa_G \log b_m + e_{N, p, m}\), with \(|e_{N, p, m} | \leqslant \delta_{m + 1}\) and \(\delta_{m + 1} / \log b_m \leqslant J (m + 1)^{- 2} \to 0\). The reset uses the one-loop estimate of III.7.

  2. Shooting and summation (III.2). For each \(N, p\) the bare coupling \(\beta_{N, p, N}\) is chosen so that the flow reaches \(\beta_{N, p, 0} = \bar{\beta}\); this is the renormalization condition at unit scale. Summing the per-step relation from step 0 to step \(m\) gives

    \(\displaystyle | \beta_{N, p, m} - \hat{\beta}_m | \leqslant \sum_{i < m} \delta_{i + 1} .\)

    Since \(\delta_{i + 1} = o (\log b_i)\) and \(s_m = \sum_{i < m} \log b_i \to \infty\), the right side is \(o (s_m)\) by a Cesàro argument. The bound is uniform in \(N \geqslant m\) and in \(p\), because the per-step bounds are.

  3. Division by \(s_m\) (this unit). Since \(\bar{\beta} / s_m \to 0\), one gets \(\beta_{N, p, m} / s_m \to \kappa_G = 2 b_0\), uniformly. Taking \(m = N\) gives (Reg1); taking square roots gives the coupling law.

The result concerns the actual inverse coupling of the trajectory, including its bare endpoint. It does not identify this quantity with a coupling defined from continuum correlations.

Part (B). The auxiliary arguments use finite-dimensional limits and equivariant linear algebra.

4. Steps

4.1 The running coupling

Lemma VII.5.a (normalisation). \(2 b_0 = \kappa_G\). Proof. Unfold both definitions. Lean: b0_normalizes.

Lemma VII.5.b (the running clause; input from III.2). Let \(\delta : \mathbb{N} \to [0, \infty)\) and \(J : \mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N}\) satisfy \(J (m) \geqslant 1\) and \(J (m) \to \infty\). With the scales and reference line of §1, suppose:

Then (R) holds.

Proof sketch.

  1. Since \(s_{m + 1} = s_m + \log b_m\), induction on \(m\) gives \(| \beta_{N, p, m} - \hat{\beta}_m | \leqslant \Delta_m := \sum_{i < m} \delta_{i + 1}\) for \(m \leqslant N\).

  2. Given \(\varepsilon\), choose \(j\) with \(J (i + 1)^{- 2} \leqslant \varepsilon / 2\) for \(i \geqslant j\). Then \(\Delta_m \leqslant \Delta_j + \frac{\varepsilon}{2} (s_m - s_j)\) for \(m \geqslant j\).

  3. For \(m\) large, \(\Delta_j \leqslant \frac{\varepsilon}{2} s_m\), hence \(\Delta_m \leqslant \varepsilon s_m\).

The constants and thresholds do not involve \(N\) or \(p\). Lean: YM.RG.Shoot.trajectory (III.2).

Lemma VII.5.c (= Proposition VII.5.1). Proof sketch.

  1. Apply (R) with \(\varepsilon / 4\). Because \(s_m \to \infty\), one may also require \(s_m \geqslant 4 (| \bar{\beta} | + 1) / \varepsilon\).

  2. Then \(s_m > 0\) and \(| \bar{\beta} | < \frac{\varepsilon}{4} s_m\).

  3. With \(\kappa_G = 2 b_0\), the triangle inequality gives

    \(\displaystyle | \beta_{N, p, m} - 2 b_0 s_m | \leqslant | \beta_{N, p, m} - \hat{\beta}_m | + | \bar{\beta} | < \varepsilon s_m .\)
  4. Divide by \(s_m\).

Lean: zeroUp_bound.

Lemma VII.5.d (= Corollary VII.5.2). Proof sketch. The slope is \(2 b_0\), which is positive because \(C_{\mathfrak{g}} > 0\) for simple \(\mathfrak{g}\). Given \(\varepsilon\), take \(N_0 := m_0\) from VII.5.1 and specialise to \(m = N\). The bare coupling of the public family is \(\beta_{N, p, N}\), and its \(\log (1 / a_N)\) is \(s_N\) by definition. Lean: YangMills.regular (VIII.1).

Lemma VII.5.e (= Proposition VII.5.3). Proof sketch.

  1. For each \(\varepsilon\), eventually both \(i \geqslant m_0 (\varepsilon)\) and \(i \leqslant N_i\). So VII.5.1 gives \(\beta_{N_i, k_i, i} / s_i \to 2 b_0\).

  2. Since \(\kappa_G > 0\) for simple \(\mathfrak{g}\), \(2 b_0 > 0\). Then \(x \mapsto \sqrt{x}\) is continuous at \(2 b_0\) and \(y \mapsto y^{- 1}\) is continuous at \(\sqrt{2 b_0} \ne 0\). Hence \((\beta_{N_i, k_i, i} / s_i)^{- 1 / 2} \to (2 b_0)^{- 1 / 2}\).

  3. For all sufficiently large \(i\), both \(s_i\) and \(\beta_{N_i, k_i, i}\) are positive, so \(\beta_{N_i, k_i, i}^{- 1 / 2} s_i^{1 / 2} = (\beta_{N_i, k_i, i} / s_i)^{- 1 / 2}\), and \(s_i = \log (1 / a_i)\) by definition.

Lean: comparison.

4.2 Normalisation of the stress tensor (VII.5.4)

Lemma VII.5.f (ratio lemma). Let \(Z\) be a finite-dimensional real normed space. If \(X_k \to x \neq 0\) in \(Z\) and \(f_k X_k \to c \hspace{0.17em} x\) with \(f_k \in \mathbb{R}\), then \(f_k \to c\). Proof sketch. Choose a linear functional \(\ell\) with \(\ell (x) \neq 0\). Then \(\ell (X_k) \ne 0\) eventually, and \(f_k = \ell (f_k X_k) / \ell (X_k) \to c\). Lean: scale_limit.

Lemma VII.5.g (= VII.5.4(a)). Proof sketch.

  1. A04 at degree 4 gives thresholds beyond which \(X_k := r_k \hspace{0.17em} U_k (5)^{- 1} \partial^V_4 U_k (4) \to x := \partial^W_4\).

  2. A05 at degree 4, applied to \((J, p, Y)\), gives thresholds beyond which \((r_k / \xi_k) \hspace{0.17em} U_k (5)^{- 1} p_4 U_k (4) \to \kappa \hspace{0.17em} \partial^W_4\).

  3. Take the componentwise maximum of the two sets of thresholds.

  4. Substituting \(p_4 = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial^V_4\) in step 2 gives \((c / \xi_k) X_k \to \kappa x\), where \(x \ne 0\) is part of the free data. Lemma VII.5.f gives \(c / \xi_k \to \kappa\).

The transport is \(U_k (d + 1)^{- 1} (\hspace{0.17em} \cdot \hspace{0.17em}) U_k (d)\), as defined by carry and aisle.

Lean: tracks_ratio.

Lemma VII.5.h (= VII.5.4(b)). Proof sketch. Suppose \(J = 0\). The translation Ward identity writes every correlation with an insertion of \(p_{d, a} v\) as a flux of \(J\) through a shell, which is then \(0\). Correlations separate the elements of \(\mathcal{F}_{d + 1}\), so \(p = 0\). Lean: flux_nontrivial.

Remark (sign of \(c \kappa\)). Suppose in addition that tracking sequences exist at every level. Then \(c \kappa > 0\): since \(\xi_k > 0\), \(c / \xi_k\) has the sign of \(c\), and its limit is \(\kappa \ne 0\). This is kappa_sign. It is not assigned to this unit and is not used by the main theorem. VI.2 uses only (a), and obtains \(c \neq 0\) from \(\kappa \ne 0\).

4.3 Exactly compatible frames (VII.5.5)

Lemma VII.5.i (equivariant retraction, = VII.5.5(a)). Proof sketch.

  1. \(\iota^W\) is injective, so it has a linear left inverse \(R\).

  2. Average over \(\Gamma_4\): \(Q := | \Gamma_4 |^{- 1} \sum_{s \in \Gamma_4} s^{- 1} Rs\). Since \(\iota^W\) commutes with \(\Gamma_4\), \(Q\) is again a left inverse, and \(Q\) is \(\Gamma_4\)-equivariant.

  3. Let \(\theta\) be the conjugation, an antilinear involution. Put \(P := \frac{1}{2} (Q + \theta Q \theta)\). Then \(P\) is \(\mathbb{C}\)-linear. It is a left inverse, since \(\iota^W\) commutes with \(\theta\). It commutes with \(\theta\). It stays \(\Gamma_4\)-equivariant, since \(\theta\) commutes with \(\Gamma_4\).

Lean: retraction, averaged_cov.

Lemma VII.5.j (exactness of the correction, = VII.5.5(b)). Proof sketch.

  1. One step. \(X_{d + 1} \iota^W v = \iota^V X_d P_d \iota^W v + A_{d + 1} (\iota^W v - \iota^W P_d \iota^W v) = \iota^V X_d v\).

  2. Intertwining for \(d \leqslant e\). Induction on \(e\), using \(\iota_{d \to e + 1} = \iota_{e \to e + 1} \iota_{d \to e}\) and \(\iota_{d \to d} = 1\).

  3. Symmetries. Induction on \(d\). Let \(g\) be a signed permutation or the conjugation. Then \(g\) commutes with \(P_d\), \(\iota^W\), \(\iota^V\), \(A_{d + 1}\) and, by induction, with \(X_d\). Hence it commutes with both terms of \(X_{d + 1}\).

  4. Units. \(\boldsymbol{1}_{d + 1} = \iota^W \boldsymbol{1}_d\), so \(X_{d + 1} \boldsymbol{1}_{d + 1} = \iota^V X_d \boldsymbol{1}_d = \iota^V \boldsymbol{1}_d =\boldsymbol{1}_{d + 1}\).

Lean: adjusted_succ, adjusted_exact.

Lemma VII.5.k (asymptotic identity). Under the hypotheses of VII.5.5(c), for \(d \leqslant D\), \(\Pi^{(k)}_d := (A^{(k)}_d)^{- 1} X^{(k)}_d \to 1\) in operator norm. Proof sketch.

  1. Put \(\Phi^{(k)}_d := (A^{(k)}_{d + 1})^{- 1} \iota^V A^{(k)}_d\). Then

    \(\displaystyle \Pi^{(k)}_{d + 1} v = \Phi^{(k)}_d \hspace{0.17em} \Pi^{(k)}_d P_d v + (v - \iota^W P_d v), \qquad \Pi^{(k)}_0 = 1.\)
  2. \(\Phi^{(k)}_d \to \iota^W\) pointwise by hypothesis, hence in norm (finite dimension).

  3. By induction, \(\Pi^{(k)}_d P_d v \to P_d v\).

  4. Therefore \(\Pi^{(k)}_{d + 1} v \to \iota^W P_d v + v - \iota^W P_d v = v\). Finite dimensionality converts pointwise convergence to operator-norm convergence.

Lean: perturb, perturb_limit.

Lemma VII.5.l (bijectivity and the new frames, VII.5.5(c)). Proof sketch.

  1. \(\Pi^{(k)}_d \to 1\) in norm, and injective operators form an open set. So \(\Pi^{(k)}_d\), and hence \(X^{(k)}_d\), is injective for large \(k\).

  2. \(\dim \mathcal{F}^{\circ}_d = \dim \mathcal{F}_d\) (by \(A^{(k)}_d\)), so \(X^{(k)}_d\) is bijective.

  3. Hence \(\tilde{X}^{(k)}_d = X^{(k)}_d\) eventually, and \((A^{(k)}_d)^{- 1} \tilde{X}^{(k)}_d v \to v\) for every \(v\).

  4. Intersect the eventual sets for \(d = 0, \ldots, D\). If the original frames satisfy the symmetry and unit conditions of (b), all corrected frames then agree with the exactly compatible maps \(X^{(k)}_d\) on this degree range.

Lean: eventually_unit, rotate_eq, relative.

Use. In VII.1 the frames of the free-field scaling sequence intertwine the inclusions only asymptotically. VII.5.5 replaces them by frames that are exactly graded for all large \(k\) and asymptotically equal to the original ones, as tracking requires (tune_grades).

4.4 Finite-dimensional convergence (VII.5.6)

Lemma VII.5.m (= Proposition VII.5.6). Proof sketch.

Lean: norm_fit, components, norm_fit_deriv.

4.5 The classical stress-tensor algebra (VII.5.7)

Lemma VII.5.n (covariance of \(\mu^1, \mu^2\)). For a signed permutation \(t\) with signs \(\varepsilon_t (\cdot)\):

\(\displaystyle t \cdot \mu^2_a = \varepsilon_t (a) \hspace{0.17em} \mu^2_{t (a)}, \qquad t \cdot \mu^1_a = \varepsilon_t (a) \hspace{0.17em} \mu^1_{t (a)} .\)

Both are real. Proof sketch. \(t\) multiplies \(\langle F_{ij}, \partial_b F_{ij} \rangle\) by \(\varepsilon (i) \varepsilon (j) \hspace{0.17em} \varepsilon (b) \varepsilon (i) \varepsilon (j) = \varepsilon (b)\) and relabels the indices. The double sum over \((i, j)\) is invariant under reindexing by \(t\). For \(\mu^1_b\), the sign is \(\varepsilon (b)^3 \varepsilon (i)^2 = \varepsilon (b)\), and the remaining index is reindexed in the same way. Reality follows from the real inner products. Lean: momentum2_turn, momentum1_mem, momentum2_mem, sumPerm.

Lemma VII.5.o (affine shells). Every degree-0 radial jet is realised by a free Maxwell field with constant curvature and an affine potential. Proof sketch. The associated potential has constant curvature, so \(\sum_a \partial_a F_{ab} = 0\). Lean: shell_affine. VII.2 uses this, with its degree-1 analogue shell_quadratic, to build test jets on Maxwell solutions.

Consequences in VI.1 and VII.2. Write \(T^{(0, w)} := T^{(0, w_0, w_1, w_2)}\) for \(w \in \mathbb{R}^3\).

  1. Trace (VI.1). \(\sum_a T^{(0, w)}_{aa} = 4 (w_0 + 4 w_1) \hspace{0.17em} \mathfrak{s}\). In particular \(T^{\text{can}}\) is traceless (mechanical_trace, conformal).

  2. Divergence (VII.2). \(\delta (w)_b = \sum_a \partial_a T^{(0, w)}_{ab}\) (euler). The key identity is the Bianchi consequence

    \(\displaystyle \sum_{a, i} \langle F_{ai}, \partial_a F_{bi} \rangle = \tfrac{1}{2} \mu^2_b .\)

    With it, the shear part \(\sum_{a \ne b} \partial_a \sum_i \langle F_{ai}, F_{bi} \rangle\) equals \(E_b + \frac{1}{2} \mu^2_b - 2 \mu^1_b\).

  3. Coordinates (VII.2). For simple \(\mathfrak{g}\), \(\beta\) and \(\delta\) are bijections \(\mathbb{R}^3 \to \mathcal{R}_1\) (coordinates1, bareCoordinates). Under the same simplicity hypothesis, \(\beta (w)\) vanishes on free Maxwell solutions if and only if \(w_0 = w_1 = 0\) (through_eq).

  4. Conservation of the canonical tensor (VII.2). \(\delta (1, - \tfrac{1}{4}, 1) = E\): \(T^{\text{can}}\) is conserved on the equations of motion (eom_vector_raw).

  5. The functional \(\rho\) (VII.2). For simple \(\mathfrak{g}\), define \(\rho : \mathcal{R}_1 \to \mathbb{R}\) by \(\rho (\delta (w)) := - 4 (w_0 + 4 w_1)\). Then \(\sum_a T^{(0, w)}_{aa} = - \rho (\delta (w)) \hspace{0.17em} \mathfrak{s}\). The functional \(\rho\) vanishes on vectors whose components vanish on free Maxwell solutions (rho, rho_eom).

For simple \(\mathfrak{g}\), a tensor in this four-parameter family is conserved on free Maxwell fields precisely when it is a multiple of \(T^{\text{can}}\) plus a constant multiple of \(\delta_{ab} \boldsymbol{1}\). With the unit term removed, its trace is determined by its divergence through \(\rho\). VII.2 uses this functional in Lease and its limiting comparison mere.

5. Where the difficulty lies

The logarithmic coupling law uses only the uniform running clause and elementary real analysis. The analytic work lies in the upstream one-loop estimate, the coupling reset and the construction of a trajectory reaching \(\bar{\beta}\) at unit scale. The auxiliary results use finite-dimensional linear algebra, equivariant averaging and scalar-ratio limits.

The result is uniform both in the volume index \(p\) and in the finer lattice level \(N \geqslant m\). Thus VII.5.3 allows arbitrary volume sequences. If inverse couplings converge as \(N, p \to \infty\) at fixed \(m\), their limits inherit the non-strict bound \(| \beta / s_m - 2 b_0 | \leqslant \varepsilon\) for \(m \geqslant m_0 (\varepsilon)\). Existence of those limits and comparison with a coupling defined by continuum correlations require separate results.

Only the leading logarithm is established here, for the coefficients of the lattice effective actions. No two-loop correction or \(\Lambda\)-parameter is asserted. The main theorem uses VII.5.1 through (Reg1), retaining only the existence of a positive slope. Proposition VII.5.3 is not used in the assembly.

The 38 auxiliary declarations serve other parts of the proof: stress normalisation in VI.2, frame correction in VII.1, convergence in III.12, and classical stress algebra and read-out estimates in VI.1 and VII.2.

6. Notation

object code name proposed notation
Casimir constant YM.Gauge.casimir \(C_{\mathfrak{g}}\) (\(= 2 q^2\) for \(SU (q)\))
slope constant YM.Gauge.slopeConstant \(\kappa_G = 11 C_{\mathfrak{g}} / (24 \pi^2)\)
one-loop coefficient b0 \(b_0 = \kappa_G / 2\); slope \(b_{\ast} = 2 b_0\)
lattice spacing at stage \(m\) Schedule.a \(a_m = 1 / D_m\)
logarithmic scale Schedule.scale \(s_m = \log (1 / a_m)\)
coupling at stage \(m\) C.path.β N p m \(\beta_{N, p, m}\); bare coupling \(\beta_{N, p} = \beta_{N, p, N}\)
reference line hatBeta \(\hat{\beta}_m = \bar{\beta} + \kappa_G s_m\)
running clause Running (R)
running coupling regulatorRun \(g_{N, p, m} = \beta_{N, p, m}^{- 1 / 2}\)
free comparison table Free \(\mathcal{F}^{\circ}_d\)
equivariant retraction retraction \(P_d\)
corrected frames adjusted, rotateChart \(X_d\), \(\tilde{X}^{(k)}_d\)
exact compatibility up to degree \(D\) Exact, Graded "exactly graded"
asymptotic intertwining Near hypothesis of VII.5.5(c)
square of the curvature square4 \(\mathfrak{s}= \frac{1}{4} \sum_{i, j} \langle F_{ij}, F_{ij} \rangle\)
canonical stress tensor raw \(T^{\text{can}}\)
weight-5 vectors momentum1, momentum2 \(\mu^1\), \(\mu^2\)
coordinates on \(\mathcal{R}_1\) basisV \(\beta (w)\)
divergence of \(T^{(0, w)}\) bareVector \(\delta (w)\)
sharp read-out bound SharpRead Definition VII.5.8

7. What remains unexplained

  1. The upstream one-loop calculation. The transfer bound is traced through the coupling reset and the one-loop shift bound in §2. The evaluation of the momentum integral giving \(11 C_{\mathfrak{g}} / (24 \pi^2)\) belongs to III.7; its analytic proof is not verified here. The coupling results in this unit take the construction conditions as hypotheses.

  2. The coupling after the limits. The assessment's Theorem 7.2 concerns \(g_W (r)\) after removal of the initial cutoff and a subsequential infinite-volume limit, together with comparison to a coupling read from continuum correlations. VII.5.3 proves the lattice-stage law. A declaration establishing the additional limits and comparison has not been identified here (tentative). The files Beacon, Hymnal and Musicology in YM/RemainderComparison are possible starting points.

  3. Existence of the comparison inputs. VII.5.4 assumes the free Maxwell data of VI.2 and a Euclidean hierarchy on \(S\); it gives a conclusion for every tracking sequence meeting its finite thresholds. It does not construct such sequences. Their existence belongs to VI.1 and VII.1. Likewise, the supply of the read-out bound in III.2 uses the hypotheses of the theorem linked in §2; the underlying one-step estimates are outside this unit.

← VII.4 Operator product expansion and contact extensions (notes)Part VII·Unit outlineVII.6 Scaling variants and fixed-field estimates (notes) →