Home·The theorem·The proof in one reading·Architecture·Units·Manuscript·Glossary·FAQ·Work items·Data·Method·Provenance·Changes
← V.3 Reconstruction for every phase and the reconstructed theory (notes)Part VI·Unit outlineVI.2 The free Maxwell stress tensor and the local Ward charge (notes) →

VI.1. Ward identities, the rotation action and the conserved stress tensor — detailed notes

Contents

1. What this unit proves 3

2. What it uses 8

3. Strategy 10

4. Steps 11

4.1 Local structure of the raw shell maps (A01–A03) 11

4.2 The collinear Ward identity 12

4.3 Normalisation \(p = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial\) (A04–A06) 15

4.4 Continuation off the line 16

4.5 Brackets (A07, A08) 19

4.6 Descent of the free rotation action (A09–A12) 20

4.7 Integration to \(O (4)\) (A13, A14) 22

4.8 The averaged stress tensor (A15) 22

4.9 Lorentz group, and assembly 23

4.10 Free-field stress algebra 24

5. Where the difficulty lies 24

6. Notation 25

7. What remains unexplained 26

The full account of unit VI.1: every proposition with its proof sketch, checked against the Lean in two rounds and edited. The condensed outline and the map of the Lean are on the unit page.

Unit page · All units · Overview

Part: VI, symmetry: stress tensor and Ward identities. Lean:

Size (approximate):

Conventions.

\(\displaystyle \mathcal{W}_K [T, P] (q ; x) = \sum_{i = 1}^n \left[ S (\ldots, T_K q_i, \ldots ; x) + \sum_b (Kx_i)_b \hspace{0.17em} S (\ldots, P_b q_i, \ldots ; x) \right], \qquad \mathcal{W}_K [T] := \mathcal{W}_K [T, \partial] .\)

By the derivative law, \(\mathcal{W}_K [T] = 0\) says \(\frac{d}{dt} |_0 S (q ; e^{tK} x) = - \sum_i S (\ldots, T_K q_i, \ldots ; x)\). This is infinitesimal rotation covariance with spin part \(T\).

1. What this unit proves

Inputs.

The table and differential plan come from IV.1. The stress, shell maps and comparison data come from VI.2, using ultraviolet inputs as specified in §2. Every result below assumes the Euclidean axioms for \(S\), unless it is a statement solely about groups or operators.

Outputs. Given the differential plan and the comparison inputs, the unit constructs:

Shells and stress laws. A window for \(x = (x_0, \ldots, x_n) \in \text{Conf}_{n + 1}\) is a real function \(\chi \in C^{\infty}_c (\mathbb{R}^4)\) that equals \(1\) near \(x_0\) and whose closed support excludes \(x_1, \ldots, x_n\). For \(B \in F_d\) and tags \(q\) at \(x_1, \ldots, x_n\), the two shells are

\(\displaystyle \Phi^{\text{tr}}_{\chi} (b) = - \sum_a \int \partial_a \chi (y) \hspace{0.17em} S (J_{ab} (y), B (x_0), q) \hspace{0.17em} dy, \qquad \Phi^{\text{rot}}_{\chi} (K) = - \sum_{a, b} \int \partial_a \chi (y) \hspace{0.17em} (K (y - x_0))_b \hspace{0.17em} S (J_{ab} (y), B (x_0), q) \hspace{0.17em} dy.\)

The integrands vanish near all insertions. Given maps \(P_b : F_d \to F_{d + 1}\) and \(A : \mathfrak{so} (4) \to \text{End} \hspace{0.17em} F_d\), the triple \((J ; P, A)\) satisfies the stress laws if

\(\displaystyle \Phi^{\text{tr}}_{\chi} (b) = S (P_b B (x_0), q) \qquad \text{and} \qquad \Phi^{\text{rot}}_{\chi} (K) = S (A_K B (x_0), q)\)

for all windows, all \(B\) and all \(q\) (Table.StressLaws, shellGrad, shellSpin, Window).

Raw hypotheses (R) (Climb.Pre):

Proposition VI.1.1 (collinear rotation Ward identity and line sums).

Hypotheses.

Conclusions.

Status: theorem.

Lean: Outer.outer, Bid.LineSum, Climb.localTurn.

Proposition VI.1.2 (normalisation of the shell maps: \(p = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial\)).

Hypotheses.

Conclusion. There is a real \(c \ne 0\), independent of the degree and coordinate axis, such that:

Status: theorem.

Lean: Bid.pressured, Bid.formed; the record is Climb.Crystal.

Proposition VI.1.3 (rotation Ward identity at all separated configurations).

Hypotheses.

Conclusion. \(\mathcal{W}_K [T] (q ; x) = 0\) for all \(n\), all \(x \in \text{Conf}_n\), all tags \(q\) and all \(K\).

Status: theorem.

Lean: Ward.global; the vanishing is Ward.Still; the hypotheses are Ward.commutes and Ward.Collinear; the sum is Ward.angular.

Proposition VI.1.4 (\(\mathfrak{so} (4)\) brackets; A08).

Hypotheses.

Conclusion. \([T_u, T_v] = T_{[u, v]}\) on every \(F_d\).

Status: theorem. Erasure for \(S\) is itself proved (A07, Lemma VI.1.q).

Lean: Work.A08.answer for Bid.A08; the conclusion is Bid.Brackets.

Proposition VI.1.5 (descent of the free rotation action). Under the hypotheses of VI.1.2, let \(c\) be its normalisation constant and put \(D = c^{- 1} Y\).

Conclusion. There are complex linear isomorphisms \(V_d : F^{\text{free}}_d \to F_d\) with these properties:

Hence \(R_d (k) := V_d \hspace{0.17em} R^{\text{free}}_d (k) \hspace{0.17em} V_d^{- 1}\), \(k \in O (4)\), is a continuous representation of \(O (4)\) on \(F_d\). It equals \(M_{\sigma}\) on \(B_4\), commutes with \(\Gamma\), and has infinitesimal generator \(D\). Call such an action, with its specified generators, a rotation port. The Ward identity of VI.1.3 holds for \(D\).

Status: theorem. The \(V_d\) are chosen independently for each \(d\). Compatibility with the inclusions comes later (VI.1.6).

Lean: Climb.descends, Spin.produces, Spin.meet, Bid.services; the transported action is Spin.morph and a port is Spin.Port.

Proposition VI.1.6 (covariance and the rotation laws; A14).

Hypotheses.

Conclusions.

Status: theorem. It uses A13: \(O (4)\) is generated by \(B_4\) and the one-parameter groups \(e^{tK}\).

Lean: Work.A14.answer for Bid.A14; Rotation.Laws, Rotation.Oriented; Work.A13.answer.

Proposition VI.1.7 (the averaged stress tensor and the Ward identity (13); A15).

Hypotheses.

Conclusion. There is a stress \(J'\) with these properties:

The translation law is the Ward identity (13):

\(\displaystyle - \sum_a \int \partial_a \chi (y) \hspace{0.17em} S (J'_{ab} (y), B (x_0), q) \hspace{0.17em} dy = \frac{\partial}{\partial x_0^b} S (B (x_0), q) .\)

Status: theorem. It uses A10.

Lean: Work.A15.answer for Bid.A15; Table.Tensorial.

Proposition VI.1.8 (Lorentz action on the labels). For (b)–(c), assume the hypotheses of VI.1.2 and choose \(V_d\), \(R\) and \(J'\) as in VI.1.5–7.

(a) \(SO^+ (1, 3)\) is generated by the spatial rotations and the coordinate boosts (A16).

(b) Let \(B^{\text{free}}\) be the Lorentz action on the free labels, which is part of the free data. Let \(B_d (\Lambda) = V_d B^{\text{free}}_d (\Lambda) V_d^{- 1}\). Then \(B_e (\Lambda) \hspace{0.17em} \iota = \iota \hspace{0.17em} B_d (\Lambda)\) for all \(d \leqslant e\) and \(\Lambda \in SO^+ (1, 3)\) (A17).

(c) The compatible actions \(B_d\) define a representation on the union of the label spaces. For every degree \(d\) and spatial axis \(i\):

Status: theorems.

Lean: Work.A16.answer for Bid.A16; Work.A17.answer for Bid.A17; Spin.wand, Spin.reach, Boundary.Spins.Descends.

Proposition VI.1.9 (the assembled record). Let the free data, the infrared triple \((J, p, Y)\) and the ultraviolet record be as in §2 (inputs 3–4). Then the six assembly clauses hold: compatibility of the raw maps, their normalisation, descent of rotations, covariance, normalisation and averaging of the stress, and compatibility of the Lorentz action with inclusions.

Hence, if \(\partial\) satisfies the inclusion and derivative laws, there exist \(c\), \((V_d)\) and \(J'\) such that the following local field laws hold:

There is also a Lorentz action descending from \(R\) (VI.1.8(c)).

Status: theorem conditional on the inputs in §2. Their production uses VI.2 and the ultraviolet units; VIII.1 assembles the resulting local field laws with the phase and reconstruction data.

Lean: Outer.commission, Bid.station, Org.Commission, Commission.picks, Org.Tab, Spec.Locals.

2. What it uses

Inputs from other units.

  1. IV.1 (limit table and differential plan).

  2. V.1 (OS chambers).

  3. VI.2 (free-Maxwell data) Org.MaxwellData:

    The free-data producer Maxwell.Free.maxwell_supplies and its stress replacement FreeStress.fire are supplied in VI.2. A12 and A10+A09 give the Casimir polynomials and the generator relations. These free-data producers assume \(G\) simple.

  4. VI.2 and III.11 (raw stress, shell maps and weak comparison).

  5. VIII.1 (assembly). Combines the local field laws obtained here with the phase decomposition and reconstruction.

Standard mathematics.

Imported constants and assumptions.

3. Strategy

Conservation and the raw shell laws make the maps \(p\) and \(Y\) compatible with inclusions, conjugation and signed permutations. Moving the center inside a fixed window gives their commutators with derivatives. To obtain a global rotation identity on a coordinate line, test the stress against a compact vector field that equals the rotation field near the insertions. Its cutoff has widths \(\lambda^{100}\) in the rotation plane, \(\lambda^{150}\) in the line direction if that direction is transverse to the plane, and \(\lambda^{300}\) in the remaining directions. Two derivative terms cancel by symmetry of the stress. Reflection positivity and spectral estimates make the remaining exterior flux \(O (\lambda^{- 1})\), so the collinear angular sum vanishes. Translation along the line then gives the transverse translation sums.

The free comparison identifies \(p = c \partial\): finitely many collinear tests have a one-dimensional kernel in the free vector-map space, and this rank condition persists along a sufficiently accurate scaling system. Dividing by \(c\) gives the collinear Ward identity for \(D = c^{- 1} Y\). Its derivatives determine the transverse Taylor series of each two-point function from an explicit analytic comparison function built from radial correlations. Positivity turns the resulting bounds on Gram-kernel jets into factorial bounds for derivatives of the corresponding OS vectors. Correlations are therefore analytic when one insertion moves while remaining extreme in some coordinate. The Ward identity propagates along finite chains of these moves; density gives it at every separated configuration.

Differentiating the global Ward identity twice gives the \(\mathfrak{so} (4)\) brackets, after row erasure is transported from the free theory. A relative-Casimir polynomial and McWeeny iteration produce exact intertwiners with the free rotation generators. Transporting the free action through them gives \(O (4)\) actions on each degree. The Ward identity implies covariance, which in turn gives compatibility with inclusions, the unit and derivatives. Haar averaging of \(c^{- 1} J\) gives the tensorial stress \(J'\) without changing its Ward laws. The free Lorentz action is transported through the same intertwiners; uniqueness for the boost ODEs makes it compatible across degrees.

4. Steps

4.1 Local structure of the raw shell maps (A01–A03)

Lemma VI.1.a (A01: compatibility). Assume (R), the derivative law and the inclusion law. Then:

Proof sketch. Each identity is tested against all words in a fixed window. The shells are fluxes of \(J\) against \(\partial \chi \otimes V\), with \(V \equiv e_i\) for \(p\) and \(V (y) = K (y - x_0)\) for \(Y\).

Lean: Work.A01.answer, translation_color, angular_hyper, cutoff_zero, flux_unit, flux_mirror.

Lemma VI.1.b (A02: moving the centre). Assume (R) and the derivative law. Then

\(\displaystyle \partial_b Y_K u + \sum_c K_{cb} \hspace{0.17em} p_c u = Y_K \hspace{0.17em} \partial_b u \qquad \text{and} \qquad \partial_b \hspace{0.17em} p_i = p_i \hspace{0.17em} \partial_b\)

on every \(F_d\) (Bid.ShellCom).

Proof sketch. Keep \(\chi\) fixed and move the centre to \(x_0 + te_b\); for small \(t\), \(\chi\) is still a window. Differentiate both shell laws at \(t = 0\).

Lean: Work.A02.answer, deriv_shellSpin, stable.

Lemma VI.1.c (A03: transversality). Assume the plan laws, the colour law for \(p\), the second identity of VI.1.b, and the line sums of VI.1.1(ii). Then \(p\) and \(\partial\) are transverse (Climb.transverse). That is: for \(x \in \text{Conf}_n\) on \(\mathbb{R}e_a\), \(b \neq a\) and \(v \in F_d^n\), the function \(y \mapsto \sum_k S (v_1, \ldots, P_b v_k, \ldots, v_n ; y)\) has vanishing jet of every order at \(x\), for \(P = p\) and for \(P = \partial\).

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A03.answer, all_line, row_D, full_jet.

4.2 The collinear Ward identity

Lemma VI.1.d (flux identity). Assume (R) and the derivative law. Let \(x \in \text{Conf}_n\) and \(K \in \mathfrak{so} (4)\). Let \(F\) be a smooth compactly supported vector field that equals \(y \mapsto Ky\) near every \(x_i\). Then

\(\displaystyle \mathcal{W}_K [Y, p] (q ; x) = - \int \sum_{a, b} \partial_a F_b (y) \hspace{0.17em} S (J_{ab} (y), q ; x) \hspace{0.17em} dy.\)

Proof sketch.

Lean: Outer.flux_value, sands, paid_zero.

Lemma VI.1.e (exterior flux estimate). Fix data and cutoff field as follows.

Hypotheses.

Conclusion. For every fixed tuple of tags \(q\), the integrand is absolutely integrable for all sufficiently large \(k\), and \(\int \partial_d \hspace{0.17em} \text{petal}_{ab} (y) \hspace{0.17em} S (J_{db} (y), q ; x) \hspace{0.17em} dy = O (\lambda^{- 1})\). The constant may depend on the tags, configuration, axes and stress, but not on \(k\). The integrand is supported in the exterior shell \(\lambda^{- c_d} \leqslant |y_d | \leqslant 2 \lambda^{- c_d}\).

Proof sketch.

Lean: Outer.blows, point_moment, alternate, budget_lock; the cutoff profile is defined in Patch.lean; the line and point estimates are in Tunnel.lean and the mass estimate is in Mass.lean. (proof read for the reduction and combination of the spectral estimates; supporting analytic inputs remain as listed in §7)

Lemma VI.1.f (collinear identity and line sums). This is Proposition VI.1.1.

Proof sketch.

Lean: draught_river, drained, axisTurn, fullTurn, stagger, vane_home.

4.3 Normalisation \(p = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial\) (A04–A06)

Lemma VI.1.g (scaling limits; A04, A05). Assume the inclusion and derivative laws, (R), and the free data of §2. For each degree \(d\), there are bounds \(d_0, N_0, m_0, R_0\), with \(R_0 \geqslant 1\), such that every track whose arity, degree, derivative and size bounds are at least \(N_0, d_0, m_0, R_0\), respectively has the following limits. Write \(X\) for its scaling system and define \(\text{aisle}_{k, d} (P)_a = U_{k, d + 1}^{- 1} P_a U_{k, d}\). At this fixed degree:

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A04.answer, Work.A05.answer, integrate_sheet_scale, recover_on; the requests are Bid.Watches and Bid.ConLap.

Lemma VI.1.h (A06 and the identification \(p = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial\)). Assume the hypotheses of VI.1.2 and the transversality conclusions of VI.1.c.

Setting.

Claims.

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A06.answer, Climb.extends_form, Bid.pressured.

Lemma VI.1.i (the normalised Ward data). With \(c\) as in VI.1.h, \(D = c^{- 1} Y\) satisfies (C) and (L). This proves Proposition VI.1.2.

Proof sketch. Divide the first identity of VI.1.b, and the identity of VI.1.1(i), by \(c\), using \(p = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial\).

Lean: Bid.formed, Bid.witnessing.

4.4 Continuation off the line

Throughout this subsection \(S\) satisfies the Euclidean axioms, \(T\) satisfies (C) and (L), and \(\partial\) satisfies the derivative law.

Lemma VI.1.j (derivatives of angular sums).

Proof sketch. Product rule. The derivative of \((Kx_k)_b\) in \(x_k^a\) is \(K_{ba}\). Use \(\partial_a \partial_b = \partial_b \partial_a\), and (C) absorbs the extra term. The second statement is induction on the order, with \(q\) generalised.

Lean: Ward.traverses, Ward.ac, Ward.jet_line.

Lemma VI.1.k (OS vectors of one insertion). Let \(\mathcal{H}_a\) be the OS space for reflection in \(\{x_a = 0\}\). Write \(\Theta_a\) for the corresponding reflection of words, including the label adjoint \(M_{\theta_a} \Gamma\). For \(x_a > 0\) let \(\text{spot} (A, x) \in \mathcal{H}_a\) be the vector of the one-point word \(A (x)\).

Lean: Ward.spot, link, responds, blooms, advancing, Analysis.represents, Ward.radial.

Lemma VI.1.l (transverse jets of the two-point function). Fix \(a \neq b\) and \(K = K^{(ba)}\). For a pair of labels \(\pi = (\pi_1, \pi_2)\) put \(\Phi_{\pi} (x_1, x_2) = S (\pi_1 (x_1 e_a + x_2 e_b), \pi_2 (0))\) on \(\{x_1 > 0\}\). Define

\(\displaystyle (\mathcal{L} \Phi)_{\pi} = (x_1 \partial_2 - x_2 \partial_1) \Phi_{\pi} + \Phi_{(T_K \pi_1, \pi_2)} + \Phi_{(\pi_1, T_K \pi_2)} .\)

Then:

Proof sketch. The first identity is the definition of \(\mathcal{W}\), by the derivative law. At \(x_2 = 0\) both points lie on \(\mathbb{R}e_a\), so (L) gives \(\mathcal{W}= 0\) for all labels. VI.1.j then gives all \(x_2\)-derivatives. This supplies the collinear jets needed for the analytic comparison.

Lean: Ward.sigma, Ward.realized.

Lemma VI.1.m (comparison function and formal uniqueness). Let \((r, \theta)\) be polar coordinates of \((x_1, x_2)\) with \(x_1 > 0\). Put

\(\displaystyle Q_{\pi} (x) = S \left( (e^{- \theta T_K} \pi_1) (re_a), \hspace{0.17em} (e^{- \theta T_K} \pi_2) (0) \right) .\)

Proof sketch. Strong induction on \(n\), for all \(\pi\) at once. For \(n \geqslant 1\), at \((t, 0)\),

\(\displaystyle t \hspace{0.17em} \partial_2^{n + 1} L_{\pi} = - \partial_2^n (L_{(T_K \pi_1, \pi_2)} + L_{(\pi_1, T_K \pi_2)}) + n \hspace{0.17em} \partial_1 \partial_2^{n - 1} L_{\pi} .\)

For \(n = 0\) the transport equation directly gives \(t \partial_2 L_{\pi} = - L_{(T_K \pi_1, \pi_2)} - L_{(\pi_1, T_K \pi_2)} = 0\). In the displayed recurrence, the first term vanishes by induction, and the last term vanishes because \(\partial_2^{n - 1} L_{\pi}\) vanishes on the whole half-line. Since \(t \neq 0\), the line is noncharacteristic.

Lean: Ward.Q, htQ, solves, PDE.sure.

Lemma VI.1.n (analytic Gram kernel).

Proof sketch.

Lean: Analysis.blossoms, bud, builds, Ward.fires, swing, Ward.pure.

Lemma VI.1.o (analyticity at an extreme point). Suppose that after moving \(x_k\) to \(x_k + se_b\), the point \(k\) is strictly latest, or strictly earliest, in coordinate \(a\). Then \(u \mapsto S (q ; x \text{ with } x_k + ue_b)\) is real-analytic at \(s\), for every \(b\) (including \(b = a\)). Hence \(\mathcal{W}_K [T]\) is real-analytic along such a move.

Proof sketch.

Lean: Ward.higher, last_adv, first_adv, Ward.channel.

Lemma VI.1.p (walks; proof of VI.1.3). A walk is a finite chain of segments. Each segment moves one point \(x_k\) along \(e_b\), and on the whole segment \(x_k\) is strictly earliest or latest in some coordinate \(a\).

Proof sketch.

Lean: Ward.stood, Walk, along, park1, pushes, line, global.

4.5 Brackets (A07, A08)

Lemma VI.1.q (A07: erasure for the limit table). The weak action law, with its alignment of \(M\), \(\Gamma\), units and inclusions, transports free row erasure to \(S\) and \(\partial\).

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A07.answer, transfer.

Lemma VI.1.r (A08: brackets). This is Proposition VI.1.4.

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A08.answer, orbital_comm, orbit_twice, defect_winds, defect_ward.

4.6 Descent of the free rotation action (A09–A12)

Fix \(d\). Index the generators by ordered pairs \(\pi = (i, j)\), with \(K_{\pi} = E_{ij} - E_{ji}\) and \(C_{\pi} =\mathcal{L}^{\text{free}} (K_{\pi})\) on \(F^{\text{free}}_d\). For tuples \(B, C\) of operators on \(F^{\text{free}}_d\) define

A tuple satisfies the perfect relations if \(X_{ij} = [X_{ik}, X_{kj}]\) for a fixed \(k \not\in \{i, j\}\). Any \(\mathfrak{so} (4)\) representation does (A09).

Lemma VI.1.s (A12: the intertwiner projection). There is a real polynomial \(z\) such that \(P = z (\Omega (C, C))\) satisfies:

So \(P\) projects onto the commutant of the \(C_{\pi}\), along \(\text{range} \hspace{0.17em} \Omega\).

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A12.answer, Spin.Works, wave.

Lemma VI.1.t (approximate to exact intertwiners).

Proof sketch of (iii).

Lean: Spin.rectify, stable, enough, onto, realize, Tracks.

Lemma VI.1.u (descent of rotations; proof of VI.1.5). Assume the hypotheses of VI.1.2. The normalised rows \(D = c^{- 1} Y\) satisfy the global Ward identity by VI.1.3.

Lean: Bid.services, Bid.currencies, Bid.imaginary, Work.A09.answer, Work.A11.answer, Spin.fine, Spin.meet, Spin.produces, Climb.descends.

4.7 Integration to \(O (4)\) (A13, A14)

Lemma VI.1.v (A13). \(O (4)\) is generated by \(B_4\) and the one-parameter groups \(e^{tK}\), \(K \in \mathfrak{so} (4)\).

Proof sketch. \(O (4)\) is generated by hyperplane reflections (Cartan–Dieudonné). The reflection in \(v^{\perp}\) equals \(g^{- 1} R_0 g\), where \(R_0\) is a coordinate mirror and \(g\) is a product of plane rotations \(e^{t (E_{ij} - E_{ji})}\) that turn \(v\) onto \(e_0\) (Givens rotations).

Lean: Work.A13.answer, reflection_conjugate.

Lemma VI.1.w (A14: covariance and laws). This is Proposition VI.1.6.

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A14.oriented, cov_parameter, unit_fixed, vectorLaw, laws_of_oriented.

4.8 The averaged stress tensor (A15)

Lemma VI.1.x (A15: Haar averaging). Under the hypotheses of VI.1.7, put \(J_0 = c^{- 1} J\), so that \((J_0 ; \partial, c^{- 1} Y)\) satisfies the stress laws. Define

\(\displaystyle J' = \int_{O (4)} k \cdot J_0 \hspace{0.17em} d \mu (k), \qquad (k \cdot J)_{ab} = \sum_{ij} k_{ai} k_{bj} \hspace{0.17em} R_4 (k) J_{ij},\)

with \(\mu\) normalised Haar measure on \(O (4)\). Then \(J'\) satisfies Proposition VI.1.7.

Proof sketch.

Lean: Work.A15.answer, normalize_flux, averageStress, tensorial_average, conserved_average, stressLaws_average, rotate_flux, Work.A10.answer.

4.9 Lorentz group, and assembly

Lemma VI.1.y (A16, A17 and the descended Lorentz action). This is Proposition VI.1.8.

Proof sketch.

Lean: exists_rest, run_boost, rise_generator, Spin.run, Spin.reach.

Lemma VI.1.z (assembly). Under the hypotheses of VI.1.9, the preceding constructions give its local field laws and Lorentz action.

Proof sketch. A01–A03 and the collinear flux argument give the raw compatibility laws. VI.1.h–i give \(c\) and the normalised Ward data. VI.1.3 and VI.1.u give the intertwiners, rotation port and global Ward identity. A13–A14 give covariance and the rotation laws; A10 and A15 give the conserved tensorial stress with the required shells. Each \(F_d\) has the free comparison isomorphism by any aligned scaling system at that degree. A16–A17 give compatibility of the Lorentz actions, and the unique lift to the union gives the final representation.

Lean: Bid.station, Commission.picks, Climb.comparison.

4.10 Free-field stress algebra

Assume \(G\) is simple. The free stress satisfies the following finite-dimensional algebraic facts:

\(\displaystyle T_{ab} = \delta_{ab} \left( w_0 + w_1 \sum_i \langle F_{ai}, F_{ai} \rangle + w_2 \sum_{ij} \langle F_{ij}, F_{ij} \rangle \right) + (1 - \delta_{ab}) \hspace{0.17em} w_3 \sum_i \langle F_{ai}, F_{bi} \rangle .\)

Here \(F_{ab}\) is the free curvature and \(w \in \mathbb{R}^4\). The Maxwell stress is \(w = (0, 1, - \tfrac{1}{4}, 1)\).

These facts feed VII.2's statement that, in the free table, the divergence map from centred, real, symmetric, \(B_4\)-tensorial stresses in \((F^{\text{free}}_4)^{4 \times 4}\) to real \(B_4\)-vector fields in \((F^{\text{free}}_5)^4\) is onto and has a one-dimensional kernel (free_rank). They are not used in the Ward chain above.

Lean: bilinear_invariant, finrank_two, finrank_one, stress_tensor, div_kernel, stress_bijective. (proof of the divergence test read; polynomial classification and dimension bounds: statement only)

5. Where the difficulty lies

The exterior flux estimate (VI.1.e) bears most of the analytic burden. Reflection positivity along axes of opposite parity gives the subpower estimate without a gap. Diagonal stress components require a separate conservation argument, since they have no odd reflection parity. The widths \(\lambda^{100}, \lambda^{150}, \lambda^{300}\) and the split at \(\lambda^{- 3000}\) make the powers in these estimates compatible.

Continuation off the line (VI.1.j–p) requires more than a smooth function with vanishing jets. The collinear Ward identities determine the transverse jets of the two-point function; Hilbert-space positivity turns those jets into uniform factorial derivative bounds and hence analyticity.

The descent (VI.1.s–u) constructs exact intertwiners from the free comparison. Lie brackets alone would give an action of a covering group after integration; they would not by themselves identify the required \(O (4)\) action or its signed-permutation subgroup. Covariance subsequently forces compatibility between degrees.

The remaining steps use compactly supported integration by parts, finite-dimensional tests, group generation, Haar averaging and uniqueness for linear ODEs.

6. Notation

object code name proposed notation
label spaces, tags, inclusions, unit Field d, Tag, rise, unit \(F_d\), \((d, v)\), \(\iota\), \(\boldsymbol{1}\)
signed permutations, conjugation Signed, mirror, conj \(B_4\), \(M_{\sigma}\), \(\Gamma\)
differential plan and its laws DiffPlan, Derivatives, Inclusions, Orientation \(\partial_a\); derivative, inclusion, orientation laws
stress, window, shells Table.Stress, Window, shellGrad, shellSpin \(J_{ab} \in F_4\), \(\chi\), \(\Phi^{\text{tr}}_{\chi}\), \(\Phi^{\text{rot}}_{\chi}\)
raw shell maps; raw hypotheses Climb.Parts (\(p\)), Ward.SpinRows (\(Y\)); Climb.Pre \(p_a\), \(Y_K\); (R)
angular sum; its vanishing localTurn, Ward.angular; Still, Collinear, commutes \(\mathcal{W}_K [Y, p]\), \(\mathcal{W}_K [T]\); (L), (C)
line sums, transversality LineSum, Climb.transverse line sums, transverse
colour space and law Colors, ColorLaw colour space
normalised data Climb.Crystal \(p = c \hspace{0.17em} \partial\), \(D = c^{- 1} Y\)
free data MaxwellData, Climb.Bel, Lighthouse, Goes \(F^{\text{free}}_d, \partial^{\text{free}}, R^{\text{free}}, \mathcal{L}^{\text{free}}, J^{\text{free}}, \kappa\)
scaling system, track, weak law Climb.Scaling, Track, ActLaw, aisle \((r_k, \xi_k, U_{k, d})\), \(\text{aisle}_{k, d}\)
cutoff field petal, vane, fuel \(\text{petal}_{ab}\), \(\lambda = e^k\)
OS vector of one insertion spot, OS.Chamber \(\text{spot} (A, x) \in \mathcal{H}_a\)
row erasure erases, Winds erasure
compatibility of spin rows Bid.Hyper compatible
perfect relations, Casimir projection Spin.rel, wave, Works, effect perfect relations, \(z (\Omega (B, C))\), \(\text{ad}_{B, C}\)
tilt, intertwiners Spin.Tilt, realH, change \(U_n\), \(V_d\)
port, transported action Spin.Port, Spin.morph, Org.mill \(R_d (k) = V_d R^{\text{free}}_d (k) V_d^{- 1}\)
rotation laws, covariance Rotation.Laws, Rotation.Oriented rotation laws; \(S (R (k) v ; kx) = S (v ; x)\)
conserved, tensorial; average Conserved, Tensorial, averageStress \(J' = \int k \cdot c^{- 1} J \hspace{0.17em} d \mu\)
Lorentz action on labels Spin.run, wand, Boundary.Spins, Descends \(B_d (\Lambda)\)
record Org.Commission, Org.Tab, Spec.Locals \((c, V, J')\); local laws

7. What remains unexplained

  1. Supporting analysis in the exterior flux estimate (probable). The reductions to spectral integrals, the point and line estimates, the diagonal mass estimate and their combination in VI.1.e were checked against the cited proofs. The proofs of the remote-gap profiles, the odd temporal variant, the contact extension on product tests, and the finite-difference and interpolation estimates were not checked in full. These are the files GapTest, Nodal/Mode/Odd, Collision/Fold/Journal, MomentFD and Nodes. In particular, the construction and normalisation of the contact extension remain inputs to the mass-estimate sketch.

  2. Free-field stress algebra (probable). The statements in §4.10 and the proof that centring and the two divergence tests select the Maxwell line were checked. The polynomial normal-form and dimension-count proofs were not checked in full. The map in the cited rank theorem has centred stresses as its domain; centring cannot be omitted from the one-dimensional-kernel claim.

  3. Production of the inputs. The immediate producers of the raw stress, shell maps, weak comparison and free data are identified in §2. Their ultraviolet hypotheses, including the annular estimates and finite comparison systems, are not discharged in this unit. The unused lattice shell-law interfaces in STRESS_FLUX are not the source of (R).

  4. Normalisation and centring. The Ward coefficient of \(J'\) is exactly \(1\). Centring is not part of the conclusion of VI.1.7; the centred trace is formed in VII.2. The stress replacement used before the weak comparison supplies \(\kappa \ne 0\) without the numerical identity \(\kappa = - \tau\). Along the scaling systems used in VI.1.u, positivity of \(\xi_k\) and \(c / \xi_k \to \kappa \ne 0\) imply that \(c\) and \(\kappa\) have the same sign. Neither sign is specified by this unit's hypotheses.

  5. Scope. The folder ownership and line counts in the header have not been independently recounted. The assignment of Shift and most of Next/BOUNDARY to V.2 is tentative. The statements above are source comparisons; Lean elaboration and the transitive axiom dependencies were not checked.

← V.3 Reconstruction for every phase and the reconstructed theory (notes)Part VI·Unit outlineVI.2 The free Maxwell stress tensor and the local Ward charge (notes) →