Home·The theorem·The proof in one reading·Architecture·Units·Manuscript·Glossary·FAQ·Work items·Data·Method·Provenance·Changes
← V.3 Reconstruction for every phase and the reconstructed theoryPart VI·Detailed notesVI.2 The free Maxwell stress tensor and the local Ward charge →

VI.1. Ward identities, the rotation action and the conserved stress tensor

Contents

1. What this unit proves 2

2. What it uses 3

3. Strategy 4

4. Steps 4

5. Where the difficulty lies 5

6. Notation 5

7. What remains unexplained 5

Code dependencies 5

Lean source 5

Additional source locations 6

Key statements 12

Part VI — Symmetry: stress tensor and Ward identities.

Turns Ward identities into symmetry actions and a conserved stress tensor on the limit theory.

Status: edited. Condensed from the unit's detailed notes, which were checked against the linked Lean in two rounds and edited; the local limitations still apply. Status meanings.

Overview · All units · Detailed notes · ← Previous: V.3 · Next: VI.2 →

Results · Inputs · Strategy · Proof steps · Notation · What remains unexplained · Code dependencies · Lean source · Key statements

Source inventory and conventions

Part: VI, symmetry: stress tensor and Ward identities. Lean: YM/Bid/Town.lean, YM/Next/ROTATIONS, YM/Ward, YM/Spin. Size: approximately 7,704 assigned lines, plus 6,100 of collinear flux estimates.

1. What this unit proves

Except for group statements, assume \(S\) satisfies the Euclidean axioms: permutation symmetry, empty normalisation, unit deletion, translation invariance, \(B_4\)- and conjugation-covariance, coordinate reflection positivity for point words and smeared tests, smoothness, and for each arity, labels and derivative order \(j\), constants \(C \geqslant 0, A \in \mathbb{N}\) with \(\|D^j S (x)\| \leqslant Cr^{- A}\) whenever \(0 < r \leqslant 1\) and maximum-norm separation is at least \(r\), uniformly in positions. The plan consists of complex-linear maps \(\partial_a : F_d \to F_{d + 1}\). Its three laws are: derivative law \(S (\ldots, \partial_a v_k, \ldots ; x) = \partial_{x_k^a} S (v ; x)\), inclusion law \(S (\ldots, \iota v_k, \ldots) = S (v ; x)\), and orientation: inclusions commute with \(M, \Gamma\), derivatives commute with \(\Gamma\), and \(M_{\sigma} \partial_b = \sum_a \sigma_{ab} \partial_a M_{\sigma}\).

The raw maps are complex-linear \(p_a : F_d \to F_{d + 1}\) and real-linear \(Y : \mathfrak{so} (4) \to \text{End}_{\mathbb{C}} F_d\); spin rows \(T\) have the latter type. Write (R) for: \(J_{ab} \in F_4\) is symmetric, \(\Gamma\)-real, \(\sum_a \partial_a J_{ab} = 0\) in \(F_5\), \(M_{\sigma} J_{ab} = \sum_{ij} \sigma_{ia} \sigma_{jb} J_{ij}\), and \((J ; p, Y)\) obeys the stress laws. For every separated \((x_0, \ldots, x_n)\), labels \(B, q\), and real \(\chi \in C_c^{\infty}\) equal to \(1\) near \(x_0\) with closed support excluding the other points, these laws for \((J ; P, A)\) are

\(\displaystyle - \sum_{a, b} \int \partial_a \chi (y) V_b (y) S (J_{ab} (y), B (x_0), q) \hspace{0.17em} dy = \left\{ \begin{array}{ll} S (P_j B (x_0), q), & V = e_j,\\ S (A_K B (x_0), q), & V = K (y - x_0) . \end{array} \right.\)

All identities concern separated insertions; no contact term is evaluated. Define

\(\displaystyle \mathcal{W}_K [T, P] (q ; x) = \sum_i \left[ S (\ldots, T_K q_i, \ldots ; x) + \sum_b (Kx_i)_b S (\ldots, P_b q_i, \ldots ; x) \right], \qquad \mathcal{W}_K [T] =\mathcal{W}_K [T, \partial] .\)

Proposition VI.1.1. Assume the derivative and orientation laws and (R). For every arity \(n\), degree \(d\), coordinate axis \(\mathbb{R}e_l\), every \(x \in \text{Conf}_n\) on that axis, all tags \(q\) and \(K \in \mathfrak{so} (4)\), \(\mathcal{W}_K [Y, p] (q ; x) = 0\). For every \(j \ne l\) and \(v_1, \ldots, v_n \in F_d\), \(\sum_i S (\ldots, p_j v_i, \ldots ; x) = 0\). Status: theorem. Lean: Outer.outer, Bid.LineSum.

Proposition VI.1.2. Assume all three plan laws, the ultraviolet record and free-Maxwell data of §2. There exists real \(c \ne 0\), independent of degree and axis, with \(p_a = c \partial_a\) on every \(F_d\). For all degrees, axes and \(K\), the rows \(D = c^{- 1} Y\) satisfy (C) \(\partial_b D_K + \sum_i K_{ib} \partial_i = D_K \partial_b\) and (L) \(\mathcal{W}_K [D] = 0\) on every coordinate axis, for all labels and \(K\). Status: theorem. Lean: Bid.pressured, Bid.formed.

Proposition VI.1.3. Assume the derivative law and spin rows \(T\) satisfying (C),(L). Then \(\mathcal{W}_K [T] (q ; x) = 0\) for every arity, separated configuration, tags and \(K\). Status: theorem. Lean: Ward.global.

Proposition VI.1.4. Assume the inclusion and derivative laws, VI.1.3's conclusion, and compatibility of \(T\): it commutes with \(\Gamma, \iota\), kills \(\boldsymbol{1}\), and \(M_{\sigma} T_K = T_{\sigma K \sigma^{- 1}} M_{\sigma}\). Assume internal row erasure: for some \(N\), every \(d \geqslant N\), and every alternating real-bilinear family \(\Delta (u, v) \in \text{End}_{\mathbb{C}} F_d\) that is \(\Gamma\)-real, covariant under determinant-one signed permutations, kills \(\boldsymbol{1}\) and preserves every \(\iota_{e \to d} (F_e)\), \(e \leqslant d\), vanishing insertion sums for all words, separated configurations and \(u, v\) imply \(\Delta = 0\). Then \([T_u, T_v] = T_{[u, v]}\) for all \(d, u, v\). Status: theorem; erasure is proved here. Lean: Work.A08.answer.

Proposition VI.1.5. Under VI.1.2's hypotheses, for every \(d\) there is a complex-linear isomorphism \(V_d : F_d^{\text{free}} \to F_d\) intertwining \(M, \Gamma\) and satisfying \(D_K V_d = V_d \mathcal{L}_K^{\text{free}}\) for every \(K\). Thus \(R_d = V_d R_d^{\text{free}} V_d^{- 1}\) is a continuous \(O (4)\) representation, equals \(M\) on \(B_4\), commutes with \(\Gamma\), has generators \(D\) satisfying the global Ward identity of VI.1.3. The \(V_d\) are chosen independently across degrees. Such an action with specified generators is a rotation port. Status: theorem. Lean: Bid.services.

Proposition VI.1.6. Assume the inclusion and derivative laws and a rotation port \(R\) with generators \(T\) satisfying VI.1.3's global Ward identity. For all \(k \in O (4)\), tags and separated \(x\), \(S (R (k) v ; kx) = S (v ; x)\). Moreover \(R\) fixes \(\boldsymbol{1}\), commutes with inclusions, retains the port properties, and \(R_{d + 1} (k) \partial_a v = \sum_i k_{ia} \partial_i R_d (k) v\) for every \(d, a, v\). Status: theorem. Lean: Work.A14.answer.

Proposition VI.1.7. Assume the derivative law, a covariant rotation action satisfying VI.1.6's laws, (R), \(p = c \partial\) with \(c \ne 0\), and generators \(c^{- 1} Y\). There exists symmetric, real, divergence-free \(J'\) with \(R_4 (k) J'_{ab} = \sum_{ij} k_{ia} k_{jb} J'_{ij}\) for every \(k\), satisfying the stress laws with \((P, A) = (\partial, c^{- 1} Y)\). The translation shell, Ward identity (13), therefore equals \(\partial_{x_0^b} S (B (x_0), q)\) for every window and labels. Status: theorem. Lean: Work.A15.answer.

Proposition VI.1.8. Spatial rotations and coordinate boosts generate \(SO^+ (1, 3)\). Under VI.1.2's hypotheses, choose \(V, R, J'\) as above: \(B_d (\Lambda) = V_d B_d^{\text{free}} (\Lambda) V_d^{- 1}\) commutes with every inclusion \(F_d \hookrightarrow F_e\), \(d \leqslant e\), for every \(\Lambda\). These actions give a representation on the union, continuous on each \(F_d\), equal to \(R_d\) on spatial rotations and commuting with \(M_{\theta_t} \Gamma\). For every \(d\), spatial \(i\) and \(v \in F_d\), its boost derivative at zero is \(- iD_{K^{(3 i)}} v\). Status: theorems. Lean: Work.A16.answer, Work.A17.answer, Spin.reach.

Proposition VI.1.9. Given §2's free data, infrared triple and ultraviolet record, all six assembly clauses hold: raw compatibility, normalisation, rotation descent, covariance, averaged stress laws, and Lorentz compatibility. With the inclusion and derivative laws, there exist \(c, (V_d), J'\) satisfying VI.1.2 and VI.1.5–8, all three plan laws and the resulting local field laws. Status: conditional theorem. Lean: Outer.commission, Commission.picks.

2. What it uses

3. Strategy

Conservation turns shell laws into collinear Ward identities; free comparison fixes their normalisation. Positivity converts collinear two-point jets into analytic OS vectors, allowing propagation to every separated configuration. Exact intertwiners transport the free rotations; covariance then gives compatibility across degrees. Rescaling and averaging give the tensorial stress, and boost ODE uniqueness gives Lorentz compatibility.

4. Steps

  1. Moving the centre inside a fixed window gives \(\partial_b Y_K + \sum_c K_{cb} p_c = Y_K \partial_b\) and \(\partial_b p_i = p_i \partial_b\) by differentiating its shell laws. Work.A02.answer.

  2. Cutoffs of widths \(\lambda^{100}, \lambda^{150}, \lambda^{300}\) cancel two terms by stress symmetry; reflection positivity and spectral estimates bound the exterior flux by \(O (\lambda^{- 1})\), giving the collinear identity without a mass gap or clustering. Outer.blows. (supporting analysis partly read)

  3. Finite free collinear tests have a one-dimensional kernel; persistence of rank under scaling forces \(p = c \partial\). Climb.extends_form.

  4. Analytic comparison determines two-point jets; positivity gives factorial vector-derivative bounds. Extreme-point moves and density propagate vanishing angular sums. Analysis.blossoms, Ward.global.

  5. Free row erasure removes the bracket defect. Relative-Casimir projection and iteration \(x \mapsto 3 x^2 - 2 x^3\) produce exact intertwiners: the compressed defect satisfies perfect commutator relations, which force sufficiently small operators to vanish. Work.A08.answer, Spin.meet.

  6. Group generation integrates covariance; Haar averaging of \(c^{- 1} J\) preserves the stress laws. Boost ODE uniqueness proves compatibility across degrees. Work.A14.answer, Work.A15.answer, run_boost.

5. Where the difficulty lies

Diagonal stress components require a conservation estimate beyond reflection-parity arguments. Vanishing smooth jets alone do not justify continuation; positivity supplies analyticity. Exact intertwiners identify the required \(O (4)\) action and signed permutations.

6. Notation

\(S\): correlation table; \(F_d\): finite-dimensional complex label spaces of degree \(\leqslant d\) modulo null labels; \(\iota\): inclusions; \(\boldsymbol{1}\): unit; \(B_4, M\): signed permutations and their action; \(\Gamma\): conjugation; \(\text{Conf}_n\): distinct points in \(\mathbb{R}^4\). \(K \in \mathfrak{so} (4)\) is real skew, with \([u, v] = uv - vu\) and \(K^{(ba)} = E_{ba} - E_{ab}\); time is axis \(3\), and \(\theta_t\) reverses it. \(\lambda = e^k\) is the cutoff scale.

7. What remains unexplained

Supporting flux analysis, including contact-extension normalisation, was not checked fully (probable). The ultraviolet hypotheses of the input producers are not discharged here. Centring of \(J'\) is not proved here; neither sign of \(c, \kappa\) is specified. Lean elaboration and transitive axiom dependencies were not checked.

Detailed notes: the full account of this unit, with proof sketches for every step, is on the detailed notes page.

Code dependencies

Code dependencies (from the compiled Lean). These lists follow references between declarations allocated to units; they can include shared definitions, record fields and alternative constructions. They are not a mathematical reading order. Only unit pairs with at least 25 references are shown; see the counting rules.

References to: I.1, IV.1, III.16, V.2, V.1, VIII.1, III.10.

Referenced by: VIII.1, VII.2, VI.2, V.2, V.3, III.6, III.10, III.11, VII.5, V.1, VII.3, III.9, VII.6, VII.1.

Lean source

Source allocation: 7,704 attributed lines; 1,014 line-counted declarations; 1,306 assigned declaration names. Of the assigned names, 1,261 are in the compiled closure of the seventeen headline results. These quantities have different scopes.

The folders and result chains below are source inventories. Their line counts cover each whole group, including any share allocated to another unit; percentages use attributed lines plus one per assigned name. They need not sum to the unit total.

Additional source locations

Further pinned locations for the definitions and comparisons discussed in this unit.

Key statements

In the selected statement order. K- identifiers name this generated list; proposition and lemma numbers in the outline are separate. Each sentence is an automatically drafted summary of a Lean statement; follow its link for the exact hypotheses and conclusion. The outline status does not certify these summaries. Main result and key result describe importance, not correctness. Full names are in the statement table.

All units · Overview of the proof · Repository

← V.3 Reconstruction for every phase and the reconstructed theoryPart VI·Detailed notesVI.2 The free Maxwell stress tensor and the local Ward charge →