Home·The theorem·The proof in one reading·Architecture·Units·Manuscript·Glossary·FAQ·Work items·Data·Method·Provenance·Changes
← VI.2 The free Maxwell stress tensor and the local Ward chargePart VII·Detailed notesVII.2 The trace of the stress tensor and the trace anomaly →

VII.1. Free Maxwell fields for the short-distance comparison

Contents

1. What this unit proves 2

2. What it uses 4

3. Strategy 4

4. Steps 4

5. Where the difficulty lies 5

6. Notation 5

7. What remains unexplained 5

Code dependencies 5

Lean source 6

Additional source locations 7

Key statements 11

Part VII — Identification as Yang–Mills.

Builds the free Maxwell correlation functions and detection estimates needed for the short-distance comparison.

Status: edited. Condensed from the unit's detailed notes, which were checked against the linked Lean in two rounds and edited; the local limitations still apply. Status meanings.

Overview · All units · Detailed notes · ← Previous: VI.2 · Next: VII.2 →

Results · Inputs · Strategy · Proof steps · Notation · What remains unexplained · Code dependencies · Lean source · Key statements

Reading scope. This unit supplies the free side of the comparison. The interacting comparison is explained in VI.2 and assembled in VIII.1.

Source inventory and conventions

Part: VII, identification as Yang–Mills. Lean: the chain of YM/Pert (folders Fourier, Align, Warp, Rig, the jet stencils of Lattice, the statement Position/Crest.finite_leading, and Dense), YM/Push/FINITE_DETECTION, YM/SharpGram/Weak, YM/SharpGram/Dense, YM/RG08 (about thirty small sub-folders), YM/PertExtension, YM/OPE/Levy. Size: 8,117 lines.

1. What this unit proves

Fix a compact matrix gauge group \(G\) with real simple nonabelian Lie algebra \(\mathfrak{g}\), invariant inner product and orthonormal colour basis. Let \(V_d\) be complex \(\text{Ad} (G)\)-invariant radial-jet polynomials of engineering weight at most \(d\), \(F_d\) their free-null quotient, \(\rho\) restriction to Maxwell jets, \(\mathcal{I}_d = V_d \cap \ker \rho\), and \(\omega_d = \rho \circ \text{sec}_d\) for the VII.3 representatives.

Proposition VII.1.1 (regulator removal). For every integer \(L \geqslant 2\), \(d, r \in \mathbb{N}\), label frames, \(p \in F_d^r\) and continuous \(f\) with compact closed support in \(\text{Conf}_r\), set \(h_m = L^{- m}\), \(N_m = 4 L^{m^2 + m + 1}\). Then

\(\displaystyle \Pi_m (f ; p) \longrightarrow \int f (x) \mathcal{W}_x (\omega_d p_1, \ldots, \omega_d p_r) \hspace{0.17em} dx.\)

For any position board with smooth compactly supported profiles in \(\text{Conf}\), order-zero readings converge slotwise for every basis-label tuple to free readings. Status: theorem. Lean: Rig.zerothProfile, Position.finite_leading.

Proposition VII.1.2 (pointwise limit). For every itinerary \((N_i, h_i)\) with \(4 \mid N_i\), \(d, r \in \mathbb{N}\), \(z \in \text{Conf}_r\), sites \(o_{i, j}\) homing to \(z_j\), and \(p \in F_d^r\),

\(\displaystyle \left\langle \prod_j R_{h_i} (\text{sec}_d p_j, o_{i, j}) \right\rangle^{(0)}_{N_i} \longrightarrow \mathcal{W}_z (\omega_d p_1, \ldots, \omega_d p_r) .\)

Status: theorem. Lean: Warp.row_limit.

Proposition VII.1.3 (corrected covariance). For every such itinerary, any index set \(\iota\), injective \(z : \iota \to \mathbb{R}^4\), homing sites \(o_{i, j}\), indices \(j, l\) and keys \(a, b\),

\(\displaystyle \text{Cov}_{\mu_{N_i}} (\ell^{h_i}_{o_{i, j}, a}, \ell^{h_i}_{o_{i, l}, b}) - \delta_{jl} S_{h_i} (a, b) \longrightarrow \left\{ \begin{array}{ll} K_{ab} (z_j - z_l), & j \ne l,\\ 0, & j = l. \end{array} \right.\)

Status: theorem. Lean: Align.corrected_limit.

Proposition VII.1.4 (detection). For every \(v \in V_d \setminus \mathcal{I}_d\),

\(\displaystyle \text{Re} \hspace{0.17em} \mathcal{W}_{(e_{\text{t}}, 0)} (\rho v, \rho (\sigma \bar{v})) > 0.\)

More generally, for the diagonalizing and reflected probe substitutions \(\Phi, \Psi\), every nonzero shell polynomial \(q\) satisfies \(\text{Re} \hspace{0.17em} \mathcal{W}_{(e_{\text{t}}, 0)} (\Phi q, \Psi \bar{q}) > 0\). Here \(\Phi\) is onto and \(\rho v = \Phi q\) implies \(\rho (\sigma \bar{v}) = \Psi \bar{q}\). Status: theorem. Lean: Free.two_detect, Free.positive.

Proposition VII.1.5 (Kelvin formulas). For every real symmetric \(j\)-tensor \(A\) with harmonic diagonal, and \(x \ne 0\),

\(\displaystyle \frac{A (\partial, \ldots, \partial) \Gamma (x)}{j!} = \frac{(- 2)^j}{4 \pi^2} |x|^{- 2 (j + 1)} A (x, \ldots, x) .\)

For every \(\mathfrak{g}\)-valued Maxwell shell tensor \(Y \in \text{Sh}_j\), contracting the curvature kernel's first rank-\(j\) Taylor leg with \(Y\), summing colours, ordered form indices and jet indices without \(1 / 2\), gives \(\gamma_j \iota^{\ast} Y^{\natural} (x)\) for \(x \ne 0\), where \(\iota (x) = - x / |x|^2\), \(Y^{\natural} (x) = Y (x, \ldots, x)\) and \(\gamma_j = 2^j (j + 1) (j + 2) / \pi^2\). Status: theorem. Lean: Kelvin.harmonic_Green, Kelvin.response_eq.

Proposition VII.1.6 (corrected charts). Fix a realized Wilson family, construction record with limit table \(S\) and extraction order \(f\), VII.4 OPE data, \(D \in \mathbb{N}\), and a nontrivial filter \(u\) on \(\mathbb{N}^2\) finer than \(f\)'s extraction filter. Assume a weak measuring Portfolio through \(D\): observable/Haar bounds, Haar chart ratio, three price panels and a dominating label-cost constant; \(g (k) \to \infty\) with eventually \(g (k) \leqslant k\) and

\(\displaystyle \text{scale} (k) \leqslant \text{scale} (g (k)) + \log \hat{\beta}_k ;\)

finite-regulator complex linear label maps eventually satisfying Poised simultaneously through \(D\) at step \(g (k)\) (degree availability, monitor bound, tested equivariant maps and all panel estimates); and rescaled read-outs converging along \(u\) to \(\Phi_{k, d}\) for every \(d \leqslant D\) and reference label. Set \(D_{k, d} = \pi_d^S \Phi_{k, d} \lambda_d\), where \(\pi_d^S\) projects to \(S_d\) and \(\lambda_d\) is the fixed equivariant representative of the free quotient in reference label coordinates, and let \(\chi_k (d) = D_{k, d}\) when bijective, a fixed isomorphism otherwise. There exist complex linear isomorphisms \(p_k (d) : F_d \to S_d\) for all \(k, d\), eventually in \(k\), simultaneously for \(d \leqslant D\), unit-preserving, commuting with signed permutations and conjugation, and satisfying

\(\displaystyle p_k (e) \iota^F_{d, e} = \iota^S_{d, e} p_k (d) \quad (d \leqslant e \leqslant D) ;\)

and \(\chi_k (d)^{- 1} p_k (d) v \to v\) for \(d \leqslant D\), \(v \in F_d\). Status: conditional theorem. Lean: Weak.Portfolio.tune_grades.

Proposition VII.1.7 (windows and expansions).

(a) Fix III.2 RG constants, Haar bounds, a Haar chart ratio satisfying the local ratio bounds, and admissible price-panel relay with activation bounds \(u_j \leqslant L_j\), eventual activation of every degree, and all comparison/analytic rank bounds. For any wait \(U\) with \(w_j (t) = \lfloor \log (\bar{\beta} + c_G t) / \log L_j \rfloor\), \(c_G > 0\), there is a wait \(W\) with no smaller stage-length/entry bounds and the same window, and panels and dominating costs at every degree. Every realized Wilson family satisfying \(W\), prescribed observable bounds and polynomial-representative conditions then, for every \(D\), has simultaneous finite-regulator comparison data through \(D\) at all sufficiently late steps \(k\) whose scale exceeds the stage entry threshold and whose backward window has length at most \(k\) and lies in one stage; returned panels satisfy all three comparison inequalities. Lean: Dense.slim_wait_for.

(b) If \(U\) has this window and \(V\) has no smaller stage-length/entry/window bounds, each \(V\) entry at stage \(j\) exceeds or equals \(U\)'s entry at \(j + 1\), and \(\bar{\beta} + c_G t \geqslant c_G\) above that \(V\) entry, every trajectory satisfying \(V\) admits \(g (k) \to \infty\) eventually satisfying the scale inequality in VII.1.6, \(g (k) \leqslant k\), and \(g (k)\) above its \(U\) entry threshold with backward \(U\) window of length at most \(g (k)\) contained in one stage. Lean: Dense.nearby.

(c) Fix finite \(I\), \(T \subset I\), \(p \in T\), \(D, k, E, q \in \mathbb{N}\), \(R \in \mathbb{R}\), \(v > 0\), \(q \leqslant k + E\). There exist \(0 < w \leqslant v\), \(C_0 \geqslant 0\), independent of layout and bound \(B\), such that every layout satisfying the prescribed tensor symmetry, rank and analytic realization conditions (Sense), depending only on occupied markers, zero on the empty set, with weights \(a_i \in \mathbb{N}\) summing to \(k\) on \(T\) and anchored \(v\)-weighted absolute-sum coefficient bounds \(B\) through order \(E\) at every leg rank, has this expansion: re-root at \(x_p\), shift order by \(q\), zero terms \(q + n < k\); through leg rank \(k + E - q\) the coefficients are Taylor coefficients of a finite sum of curvature expressions of ranks \(\max (k - q, 0), \ldots, k + E - q\). These depend only on \(T\), retain symmetry and analytic realization, and have anchored absolute-sum bound \(BC_0\) with weight \(\exp (w \hspace{0.17em} \text{girth})\), including relative marker positions. Lean: Dart.coin_pre. Status (a–c): theorems, modulo imported station and curvature-lifting estimates whose full proofs are outside this verification (probable; see §7).

2. What it uses

3. Strategy

At order zero the normalized expectation is Gaussian. Independent imaginary Gaussians subtract the infinite-lattice self-contractions at each insertion. Fourier analysis gives Maxwell pairings between distinct insertions and zero limits for corrected self-pairings. The common Wick deletion recursion then gives polynomial moments; compactness and dominated convergence give tested limits.

Translated inversion produces a triangular change of probe variables with diagonal positive reflected pairings. Wick matchings give strict positivity on nonzero shell polynomials. Interacting rank estimates transfer detection to raw charts; fixed equivariant retractions remove their filtration defects recursively.

4. Steps

  1. Invert the gauge-fixed form: covariance is direct torus Green function minus its reflected image. Orb.covar_link.

  2. Fourier annuli give separated limits; fixed-offset quadrature controls self-contractions. Align.chart_limit, Align.chart_return.

  3. Induct on distinguishable legs using the shared deletion recursion; compactness and dominated convergence give profiles. Warp.earth, Rig.grid_limit.

  4. Kelvin translation makes probes triangular; diagonal positive pairings give positive Wick monomial norms and finite detection. Free.pairing_var, free_injective.

  5. Rank estimates give moving-detector convergence; free detection and recursive retractions yield compatible charts. Portfolio.twoC, tune_grades.

  6. Raise entry thresholds so all active estimates fit the logarithmic window; near a stage boundary choose the preceding stage's last usable step. slim_wait_for, nearby.

  7. Re-root and reduce exponential weights, then lift and subtract successive lowest coefficients to obtain local curvature expressions with controlled bounds. coin_pre.

5. Where the difficulty lies

Oscillatory Fourier cancellation must survive differentiation. The chosen volume growth controls the amplified same-insertion errors; quarter-period centring removes reflected images. Detection needs strict positivity, including constants. No optimal volume growth rate is asserted.

6. Notation

\(\text{Conf}_r\): distinct \(r\)-tuples in \(\mathbb{R}^4\); \(\Gamma (x) = (4 \pi^2 |x|^2)^{- 1}\); \(K\): Maxwell jet kernel; \(\mathcal{W}\): Wick moments without same-insertion pairings. \(\mu_N\): Gaussian on reflection-odd link fields; \(\ell^h\): linear radial jet; \(S_h\): infinite-lattice self-covariance; \(R_h (p, o) =\mathbb{E}_{\xi} p (\ell_o^h + i \xi)\) with independent \(\xi \sim \mathcal{N} (0, S_h)\) (column); \(\langle \cdot \rangle^{(0)}\): coupling-series constant coefficient. \(\Pi_m\): centred \(h_m^{4 r}\)-weighted sum of \(f\) times the order-zero product correlation. An itinerary has even \(N_i\), \(h_i > 0\), positive integer \(N_i h_i \to \infty\), \(h_i \to 0\), \(N_i h_i^n \to \infty\) for every \(n \in \mathbb{N}\); homing means \(h_i (o_i - c_{N_i}) \to z\), \(c_N = (N / 4, \ldots, N / 4)\), using centred lifts. \(\sigma\): time reflection; \(e_{\text{t}}\): time unit vector; \(\text{Sh}_j\): symmetric Taylor/antisymmetric form tensors with homogeneous fields solving \(dF = d \ast F = 0\); Taylor coefficients include \(1 / j!\). A key \(a = (j, \alpha)\) is a coordinate on \(\mathfrak{g}\)-valued radial-gauge homogeneous potentials of degree \(j + 1\), with engineering weight \(j + 2\); \(K_{ab}\) uses these coordinates after inverse curl from the shell. A bar denotes complex conjugation; \(\iota^{\ast}\): 2-form pullback; \(\iota^{F, S}\): filtration inclusions.

7. What remains unexplained

Lower Fourier uniformity estimates remain unchecked (probable). Station and curvature-lifting estimates are imported (probable); remaining RG/perturbative-extension packages are unexplained (tentative). The interacting short-distance theorem belongs to VIII.1; this unit gives no all-orders comparison.

Detailed notes: the full account of this unit, with proof sketches for every step, is on the detailed notes page.

Code dependencies

Code dependencies (from the compiled Lean). These lists follow references between declarations allocated to units; they can include shared definitions, record fields and alternative constructions. They are not a mathematical reading order. Only unit pairs with at least 25 references are shown; see the counting rules.

References to: I.1, III.16, VII.3, III.7, IV.1, III.1, III.11, II.1, III.2, II.2, III.6, VIII.1, III.5, VI.2, III.4, III.3, III.10, VII.4, VI.1.

Referenced by: III.2, VIII.1, VII.2, III.13.

Lean source

Source allocation: 8,117 attributed lines; 1,626 line-counted declarations; 2,077 assigned declaration names. Of the assigned names, 1,917 are in the compiled closure of the seventeen headline results. These quantities have different scopes.

The folders and result chains below are source inventories. Their line counts cover each whole group, including any share allocated to another unit; percentages use attributed lines plus one per assigned name. They need not sum to the unit total.

Additional source locations

Further pinned locations for the definitions and comparisons discussed in this unit.

Key statements

In the selected statement order. K- identifiers name this generated list; proposition and lemma numbers in the outline are separate. Each sentence is an automatically drafted summary of a Lean statement; follow its link for the exact hypotheses and conclusion. The outline status does not certify these summaries. Main result and key result describe importance, not correctness. Full names are in the statement table.

All units · Overview of the proof · Repository

← VI.2 The free Maxwell stress tensor and the local Ward chargePart VII·Detailed notesVII.2 The trace of the stress tensor and the trace anomaly →